Lisa Schirch
Social Media Impacts on Social & Political Goods
7
Social Media Impacts on Social & Political Goods:
A Peacebuilding Perspective
Lisa Schirch
The Toda Peace Institute and the Alliance for Peacebuilding are hosting a series of policy
briefs discussing social media impacts on social and political goods. Over the next several
months, top experts and thought leaders will provide insight into social media’s threats
and possibilities. The Executive Summary provides a conceptual overview and a set of policy recommendations to address social media threats to social and political goods. The
Full Report provides a more in-depth literature review and explanation of key themes.
Ideally, the Executive Summary and the Full Report are read together, as the policy recommendations are found in the Executive Summary.
FULL REPORT
An Introduction to Media Effects on Social and Political Goods
1. All forms of media hold the potential for both
threatening and securing social and political
goods. Media is, as its Latin root suggests, “in
the middle”; it is a channel for communication
between people to either achieve – or destroy –
social and political goods.
Social goods refer to actions, resources, or anything that benefits social relationships such as education,
clean
water,
healthcare, safety, empathy, understanding, and a
sense of community.
2. The fantasy of fixing social problems with
technology has a long history. In Here Comes
Political goods refer to the
Everybody, Clay Shirky observes, “For a hundred
institutions, rule of law, and
years after it started, the printing press broke
decision-making processes
more things than it fixed, plunging Europe into a
that protect and create soperiod of intellectual and political chaos that
cial goods.
ended in the 1600s. (Shirky, Here Comes
Everybody: The Power of Organizing without Organizations 2008, 73) Social
media is a tool, and as with most tools, it can be used for both good and evil. In
their book on Liberation Technology: Social Media and the Struggle for Democracy, Diamond and Plattner describe the internet as “a “cyberstew”; a widely
divergent mix of actors and motives, where “liberation and control, transparency and deception, cooperation and predation, tolerance and extremism all
vie with one another” both to “boost democracy” and “enable repression.”
(Shirky, Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing without
Organizations 2008, xiii)
3. Social media is distinct from other media in at least six ways known as the
6Vs: volume, variety, velocity, value, veracity, and variability. Social media significantly increases the ability for diverse people and groups to communicate,
share, cooperate, and take collective action without the guidance of institutions