Freedom of Expression During Myanmar’s Revolution: The Gap Between Legal Provisions and Practice
5.3 Sagaing Federal Unit Interim Constitution
Although the Sagaing Federal Unit Interim Constitution clearly recognises freedom of
expression and related freedoms as fundamental rights, it also states provisions that
allow for the re-restriction these rights. Sagaing Region is one of the strongest areas
of armed resistance, and from a legal perspective, it possesses one of the
constitutional frameworks most closely aligned with international standards.
However, the lack of clarity in restrictive legal terminology, together with fragmented
administrative authority in the Sagaing Region, has led these legal provisions to fail
to provide effective protection in practice.
5.3.1 Legal Recognition of Freedom of Expression and the Lack of Clarity in
Restrictions
Chapter Two of the Sagaing Federal Unit Interim Constitution, titled “Fundamental
Rights, Entitlements, and Duties,” explicitly recognises freedom of expression and
related rights such as the right to write, publish, access information, and distribute
information17, as fundamental rights of all citizens. It also affirms freedoms of
assembly, peaceful expression, and the right to form and join associations as
citizens’ rights.
Regarding the protection of rights, Article 41(a) of this constitution provides that
individuals whose human rights have been violated may file a complaint at the
Federal Unit’s human rights commission and seek legal protection. Article 41(b) also
affirms that citizens can obtain protection in accordance with the provisions of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights.18
However, when specifying the circumstances under which freedom of expression
may be restricted, the Constitution does not clearly articulate the standards of
legality, necessity, and proportionality as required under international human rights
law. At the end of Chapter Two, “Fundamental Rights, Entitlements, and Duties,” it
17
18
Sagaing Federal Unit Interim Constitution
Sagaing Federal Unit Interim Constitution
21