Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 52 (2020)
Crime as Cognitive Constraint
reinforce public discourse against the Rohingya by “extending” preexisting relationships and cultural practices. The echo-chamber effect
of the platform, where users’ newsfeed would show content conforming
to their preferences, facilitated the “visually assisted claim-making”
that has proven useful for portraying the image of Muslims as a religious
“Other,” and whose seemingly evil practices clashed with Buddhism’s
virtues. 53 Facebook posts thus merged “into a sonic background in
which their recurrence [was] significant not for their detail but for their
tonal consistency,” a “mnemonic recitation” confirming “both the
existence of the threat as perceived and, also, of the community of
perceivers.” 54
With the sudden opening of the country to democracy, foreign
investment, and technology, Myanmar has been confronted with what
Amy Chua calls “the paradox of free-market democracy”. 55 Developing
nations are suddenly bombarded by market-compatible ideologies on
one hand, and “potentially market-subversive” ethno-nationalism on
the other hand. 56 As mentioned, purveyors of hate speech ranged from
41f1ff8baf3b237782313/1454645026098/Sticks+and+Stones.pdf; Detailed
Findings of the FFM, supra note 7, ¶¶ 1310, 1352. This conclusion is
supported by academic scholarship highlighting the paradoxical
“emancipatory capacity” of the Internet and mobile devices in developing
nations, along with the ability to “enhance existing social, economic, and
knowledge divides.” Leong, supra note 48, at 143 (citing Sinikka Sassi,
Cultural Differentiation or Social Segregation? Four Approaches to the
Digital Divide, 7 NEW MEDIA & SOCIETY, October 2005, at 684; DiMaggio
et al., Digital Inequality: From Unequal Access to Differentiated Use, in
SOCIAL INEQUALITY 355 (Kathryn Neckerman ed., 2004); PIPPA NORRIS,
DIGITAL DIVIDE: CIVIC ENGAGEMENT, INFORMATION POVERTY, AND THE
INTERNET WORLDWIDE (2001); Jan A.G.M. van Dijk, Digital Divide
Research, Achievements and Shortcomings, 34 POETICS 221 (2006)).
53.
GERARD MCCARTHY, ROUTLEDGE HANDBOOK OF CONTEMPORARY MYANMAR
95-96 (Adam Simpson, Nicholas Farrelly & Ian Holliday eds., 2018)
(discussing, as an example, the disaster relief operations which both
Muslims and Buddhists used to portray that their respective religions
were models of virtue and selflessness that the other group apparently did
not possess).
54.
Matt Schissler, New Technologies, Established Practices: Developing
Narratives of Muslim Threat in Myanmar, ISLAM AND THE STATE IN
MYANMAR: MUSLIM-BUDDHIST RELATIONS AND THE POLITICS OF
BELONGING 211, 232 (Melissa Crouch ed., 2015). See also Leong, supra
note 48, at 143 (discussing how mobile phone studies show how users
“incorporate cultures and cultural needs into mobile phones, expressed in
language, habits, and assistance”).
55.
Chua, supra note 44, at 288.
56.
Id. at 315 (defining ethnonationalism is one in which the nation is “defined
in terms of assumed blood ties and ethnicity”). See also Buddhism and
State Power in Myanmar, supra note 36, at 8 (describing Buddhist
nationalist sentiments against economic networks of the Chinese in
Mandalay and Taunggyi).
154