narratives, and attacking dissidents. Content promoted by China-backed manipulators typically
attempt to discredit the legitimacy of protesters and promote a positive image of the Chinese
government. Some messages have promoted conspiratorial narratives blaming the west for
sowing unrest in Hong Kong (Borat, 2019). Accounts found by Twitter and Facebook that were
used to promote these messages were hacked, automated, and fake accounts (Kao and Li,
2020).
A typical strategy that has been used for attacking dissidents is “doxing”, which refers to the
publishing of private information belonging to a particular individual with the intent of
provoking harassment or physical harm. In November 2019, Hong Kong’s Privacy
Commissioner for Personal data has reported approximately 2,000 cases of doxing since the
protests began. Some of the websites that store these lists of dissident information are based on
mainland-Chinese or Russian servers and use so-called bulletproof anonymous hosting.
Bulletproof hosting is a service provided by web hosting firms that allows their customers to
upload materials that are usually not allowed to be distributed by many regular service
providers. By doing so, bulletproof hosts usually allow content providers to bypass the terms
of service regulating Internet content in a specific country. These sites have been promoted by
groups that are linked to the Chinese Communist Party, which is believed to be responsible for
over two hundred cases of doxing (Chan & Blundy, 2019).
Taiwan Elections: A recent study by the V-Dem Institute at the University of Gothenburg in
Sweden has found Taiwan to be the country most exposed to foreign false news dissemination.
So-called content mills have been disseminating fake news around the country, specifically
messages against incumbent president Tsai Ing-Wen who has been a main advocate for
disengagement from China. These stories include one that accused her of lying about her
Doctorate degree (Kuo & Yang, 2019).
Besides spreading fake news, these media manipulators have been introducing other novel
ways in which they can manipulate opinions, argues Jarvis Chiu, senior manager for the
Institute of Information Industry in Taiwan. These include armies of trolls that leave comments
in strategic places and by such try to shift the focus of the debate. Moreover, fake accounts
have been used to share pro-Beijing messages and amplify specific content, while “subliminal
attacks” have included repeatedly searching for a candidate’s name in order to influence search
algorithms. These attacks have not been directly linked to Chinese state actors, however, some
links have been found, including one Chinese defector, Wang Liqiang, who revealed that he
was instructed to interfere in Taiwan’s midterm elections in 2018, as well as the presidential
elections held in race in January 2020 (Kuo & Yang, 2019).
COVID-19: Italy’s recent battle with the COVID-19 pandemic has received tremendous
attention from Chinese disinformation campaigns. With the outbreak of the pandemic in Italy,
China has enhanced its dissemination of carefully picked bits of information and narratives
depicting it as an ally and saviour of the Italian people. In addition to artificial amplification
techniques, such as hashtag manipulation by coordinated bots, it has also partaken in the
creation of fake info-graphs and videos. These messages were then widely shared by official
accounts tied to the Chinese Government, such as the Chinese embassy, official state media,
and other official representatives (DFRLab, 2020).
73