Victoire Rio, an adviser at the Myanmar
Tech Accountability Network, told us
that well before the election in 2020,
her group was raising red flags to
YouTube about problematic activity on
the platform, including the proliferation
of channels amplifying pro-military disinformation. In one instance, she says,
videos hosted on YouTube were linked
to an email campaign impersonating,
or “spoofing,” the accounts of election
commission officials to add credibility to
phony voter-fraud claims. Though YouTube had adopted a policy against false
claims of widespread electoral fraud in
the U.S., which the company has since
expanded to Germany and Brazil, it has
not applied the policy in Myanmar.
Rio also expressed concern about
the role of financially motivated actors
who exploit YouTube videos about
Myanmar and as a result spread falsehoods across the broader information
ecosystem. Her research on a network
of Cambodian and Vietnamese clickbait
purveyors informed an extensive report
by MIT Technology Review in 2021,
which described how Google and Facebook monetization programs had the
effect of amplifying disinformation: Opportunistic Cambodians and Vietnamese repost viral YouTube videos from
Myanmar on blogs and Facebook, not
for political purposes, but to monetize
views. In some cases, footage that originally had been uploaded to YouTube as
evidence of human rights violations was
repurposed in this manner and, in the
process, misled viewers into thinking
that the abuses were happening again.
This kind of profit-motivated manipulation of video content has inadvertently
intensified the confusion and fear felt by
Myanmar citizens who are bombarded
with propaganda from their military
rulers and other murky sources.85
YouTube says it is responding to
problems in Myanmar when it discovers channels or content that violate its
terms of service. It terminated a number of channels that MIT Technology
Review brought to its attention in 2021.
In the wake of the February 2021 coup
and subsequent army crackdowns,
YouTube told us that it has “removed
18
thousands of videos and hundreds of
channels” for promoting violence or
ethnic hatred. For example, in August
2021, it terminated 137 channels that
were part of a coordinated Burmeselanguage campaign that supported the
military coup.86
But Rio says that in Myanmar, the military and its allies often simply start new
channels, or continue to exploit others
that the company has not yet removed.
“Instead of rooting them out, they are
just addressing them one channel at a
time or one video at a time,” says Rio.
Like Mnemonic’s Kayyali, Rio believes
that YouTube has invested inadequate
resources to address these complex
challenges.
Dangerous exploitation of YouTube
crops up in unexpected ways—in one
instance, whipping up hostility to migrant workers from Myanmar who seek
employment in neighboring Thailand.
During the pandemic, a Thai civil society
group called Social Media Monitoring
for Peace pointed out a wave of hateful
attacks by Thai people on YouTube and
other platforms. One Thai YouTube
commenter said: "Wherever you see
Myanmar people, shoot them down.”87
“
The army coup was cheered
by dozens of pro-military
YouTube channels, some
with millions of views,
that spread falsehoods
undermining the election
in 2020 of a fragile civilian
government, which was then
swept aside by the military
just a few months later.
”
HOW YOUTUBE SPREADS HARMFUL CONTENT – AND WHAT CAN BE DONE ABOUT IT