A/HRC/39/CRP.2
960. Within these affected villages, approximately 37,700 individual structures were
destroyed.2168 The vast majority were Rohingya homes, but the Mission has established that
other buildings, including markets,2169 religious schools (madrassas) and mosques, 2170 were
also destroyed. The majority of the detected damage, approximately 80 per cent, was already
visible in satellite imagery as of 16 September 2017. By that date, approximately 30,800
structures had already been destroyed in 279 villages. 2171 As such, the majority of the
destruction occurred in the first three weeks of the “clearance operations”, consistent with
the timing of the most serious incidents in this report. However, the burning of houses and
structures continued over an extended period, until at least March 2018.2172
961. Villages were burned by Tatmadaw soldiers and ethnic Rakhine. Much of this burning
was done manually, through the use of flammable liquids thrown onto the buildings and set
alight using matches and through lighting buildings with flaming torches. Tatmadaw soldiers
also used weapons referred to by many victims as “launchers” and described as making loud
explosive sounds, after which a whole building, or set of buildings, rapidly caught fire.
“Launcher” likely refers to a weapon that fires a munition that explodes upon impact. Victims
generally described a hand-held or shoulder-mounted weapon, but some also described
weapons fixed to the ground using some sort of support. Victims were most likely describing
a portable anti-armour weapon such as an RPG-7 (rocket propelled grenade launcher) or the
M-3 Carl Gustav recoilless rifle, both of which are used by the Tatmadaw and match the
description in terms of both use and results. It is likely that both rocket launchers and mortars
were used by Tatmadaw soldiers to destroy buildings and homes.
962. The accounts collected further demonstrate the systematic and planned nature of the
burning of villages. Burning followed a regular pattern. Interviewees describe “launchers”
being fired by soldiers directly into Rohingya-inhabited areas, often at night or very early
morning, and setting one or more structures on fire. The ethnic Rakhine played a role, burning
Rohingya homes manually, house to house, often equipped with cans of petrol among other
equipment.2173 In some villages, other minorities fulfilled this role.2174 For example, in Mee
Chaung Zay, Buthidaung Township, interviewees stated that members of the Hindu minority
and Tatmadaw soldiers burnt their village together. The Hindus were recognised from barber
shops in the nearby Bazar. 2175 The participation of ethnic Rakhine and other ethnic
communities in the burning was often coordinated with the Tatmadaw operations. In many
locations, ethnic Rakhine methodically set fire to houses, alongside the soldiers. 2176 One
Rohingya from Kyauk Pan Du, Maungdaw Township, explained:
2168
2169
2170
2171
2172
2173
2174
2175
2176
224
UNOSAT estimated the number of destroyed structures in the affected townships between 25 August
2017 and 18 March 2018 by carrying out a damage assessment using statistical predictive analytics
based on a simple linear regression. This involved identifying a sample of representative areas and
performing a structure count in these areas. This created a “sample dataset” which was then used to
estimate the number of structures destroyed within the identified damaged areas across the three
townships. UNOSAT estimate a margin of error in counting as low as 10 per cent.
BI-002, CI-189, CI-192, CI-194, QI-106, RI-008.
BI-002, CI-009, CI-028, CI-042, CI-102, CI-103, CI-108, CI-114, CI-129, CI-135, CI-189, EI-017, EI066, LI-076, QI-001, QI-070, RI-015, RI-016, WI-005, WI-006, WI-009, WI-012, WI-013, WI-014,
WI-017, YI-001, YI-013, YI-019 YI-030.
According to UNOSAT, due to the presence of extensive cloud cover in the imagery collected during
this period, the damage analysed is very likely underestimated. UNOSAT subsequently collected
additional images of those areas, which were covered by clouds on 16 September and identified
additional damage in 10 villages affecting approximately additional 1,700 individual structures. Given
the pattern of the damage and the presence of fire detections on those areas, it is likely that this
destruction might have occurred before 16 September 2017.
Satellite image analysis prepared for the mission by UNITAR-UNOSAT.
CI-036, CI-120, CI-124, CI-125, LI-066, LI-069, LI-102, LI-118, LI-120, LI-129, LI-132, QI-002, QI005, QI-115, WI-007, WI-014, WI-032, WI-016, XI-002, XI-003, XI-005, YI-006, YI-013, YI-014,
YI-015, YI-018, YI-021, YI-030.
CI-125, CI-135, CI-148, EI-057, LI-044, LI-119, QI-012, QI-022, QI-035, QI-109, WI-044.
CI-135, LI-044.
CI-124, LI-066, LI-119, WI-016, YI-006, YI-014.