7/24/25, 11:18 AM
Fourth draft Sagaing Constitution lacks fundamental rights - Human Rights Myanmar
government, or activism. For example, the military routinely claims that it is
preventing “hatred” or protecting “dignity” when it represses dissent.
Risk of violating international law
Previous drafts of the Sagaing Constitution lacked key human rights protections.
However, the fourth draft introduces language that risks violating international
law.
Under international human rights law, some rights are absolute and may never be
restricted under any circumstances. These include the right to freedom of opinion,
the prohibition of torture and cruel treatment, and the prohibition of slavery. Yet
Sub-clause K appears to allow all rights, without exception, to be limited in the
name of “public safety”, preventing “incitement”, or to protect the “dignity” of
individuals or organisations. This creates legal uncertainty and could be
interpreted in ways that undermine absolute rights. For example, a future
government could claim torture is lawful if it is done to protect somebody’s
dignity.
Recommendations
The fourth version of the Sagaing Constitution and the public consultation process
reflect the Sagaing Parliament’s willingness to engage with democratic norms,
setting a new positive precedent in Myanmar’s legal history.
The drafters must now build upon this progress by
strengthening the content of
the Sagaing Constitution’s human rights protections. A constitution that
enshrines clear, enforceable, and modern rights, in language that meets
international standards, will not only support democratic governance in Sagaing
but also serve as a model for a future federal Myanmar.
HRM remains ready to offer legal support and analysis to assist in this process.
https://humanrightsmyanmar.org/fourth-draft-sagaing-constitution-lacks-fundamental-rights/
4/6