(Berkeley Library 2021). This could range from
having a dedicated tab for fact checking in the
online versions of newspapers and television
channels, to dedicating a separate space in the
program line-up to fact checking.
According to Taeksoo Cho, JTBC started a factchecking program around 2016–2017 to tackle
information disorder related to the impeachment
of the then president of South Korea. As one of
the largest media organizations in South Korea,
JTBC allocates five minutes of their prime-time
news bulletin to fact checks of popular news items
(interview, 2021).
Even in countries with relatively prosperous
socio-economic conditions, such as Japan and South
Korea, fact checking is still a new phenomenon. As
Jun Sakamoto noted, traditional media in Japan,
such as newspapers, are beginning to engage in
fact checking (interview, 2021). According to Gi
Woong Yun, Vail M. Pittman associate dean and
professor at the Reynolds School of Journalism of
the University of Nevada, Reno, a similar pattern can
be observed in South Korea, as “many traditional
media organizations [in South Korea] are doing
their own fact checking” and “even the public
media broadcast[ers] have fact-checking sections”
(interview, 2021).
SELECTING INFORMATION FOR FACT
CHECKING
The general selection criteria for fact checking
include the virality of the story, the risk that it would
lead to violence, and general public interest. As
Yvonne Chua, associate professor of journalism at
the University of the Philippines, Diliman, explained,
“the focus is really on claims that are factual and
have gained traction or have the potential to gain
traction.” She added: “It should be of a high public
importance, the ones that are going viral or have the
potential to go viral, and the ones that are extremely
harmful” (interview, 2021). Asel Sooronbaeva, a fact
checker and journalist from Factcheck.kg/Media
Development Center of Kyrgyzstan, explained that
they determine the need to fact check a certain
news item based on sensitivities around it and also
the impact it would have on peace and harmony in
the country and the region.
Prominent organizations in the industry have
developed guidelines and criteria to follow during
the process of selecting what to check (Borel 2020;
Buttry 2020). Fact-checking organizations that are
members of the IFCN follow the internationally
recognized process of fact checking (see IFCN
2016). This process is recognized by legitimate
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
fact checkers, as it allows them to maintain strong
standards in their process and avoid bias.
Fact checkers also rely on their intuition in
selecting stories. Many fact checkers do not limit
themselves to specific themes or topics of interest,
while others focus on specific themes such as
health, politics, and entertainment. We also found
some fact-checking organizations that focus only
on speeches or statements made by public figures
in their country.
Fact checkers sometimes receive suggestions
from readers and viewers regarding news items
that need to be checked. This happens mostly as
a result of fact checkers maintaining
an active social media presence.
We found some factAccording to Duman Smaqov,
checking organizations that
regular readers reach out to request
focus only on speeches or
specific fact checks, and also tag the
statements made by public
Factcheck.kz team in social media
figures in their country.
posts that they want fact checked
(interview, 2021). Dr. N. Tamilselvi
explained that during their selection process, she
and her collaborators “select information that
sometimes people forward—I mean, they send it to
us asking us to debunk it, asking us whether it is
true” (interview, 2021).
Fact checkers also have to consider the amount
of time and effort needed to check a story. They
might have to decline simply because the required
time and resources cannot be justified in the
context of limited funds and other resources that
most fact-checking organizations operate in.
Another consideration is that the more time is spent
on a fact check, the more public interest in the story
wanes; this also impacts on the decision-making
process.
OUTPUT FORMATS
The outputs produced by fact checking can take
various forms. The channel of dissemination can
have an impact on this, but, more than that, the
types of stories that fact checkers are targeting
affect the form their output takes (Walter et al.
2019). For example, a quick turnaround is required
for some news items due to the nature of the news
article; fact checks on news stories that have the
potential to lead to violence are an example. On
the other hand, some stories require more time
and energy and are less urgent. Such fact checks
would resemble longer investigative journalistic
pieces of writing. Duman Smaqov spoke about
the different types of fact checks produced
by Factcheck.kz, which included standard fact
checks and investigative pieces. Factcheck.kz uses
Asia – 2 02
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents