in some parts of Nepal. Women are discriminated
against and beaten, widespread violence
continues, [they are charged with] witchcraft.
[...] These stories are even highlighted by the
news media and newspapers, mainstream
newspapers, with photographs [taken] without
their permission, stating that, yes, witchcraft
exists. (interview, 2021)
Other problems include censorship of the media
through suppressive political and legislative
environments. These issues will be discussed
further later on in the report.
WORD OF MOUTH
Another important medium for the spread of misand disinformation is word of mouth. For example,
Vigneswara Ilavarasan described the phenomenon
in India as follows:
Say my father receives a message, but he cannot
interpret it. So his friends, who are supposedly
slightly educated, they are the gatekeepers,
and they share this information with their
group of friends. Political parties, especially in
this country, are able to exploit this very nicely.
So at the central city level there is an IT cell of
each of the political parties, and they create
content and pass it down to the last level. The
last person spreads it to the rest of the people
offline, physically. So if you ask me what is the
exact device they’re looking at to receive this
information, I can say that a lot of people are
looking at Twitter and Facebook; they’re receiving
all this information. The next level of information
is coming on WhatsApp and YouTube. We have
an interesting segment of people who look at
content only on YouTube. The first set of people
access all kinds of platforms. The second set of
people are looking at WhatsApp and YouTube,
and the third set—other people—are basically
dependent on people who access WhatsApp and
YouTube. They are offline! But they are the ones
who believe this, who follow this. For example,
for [Covid-19] it was said that you are supposed
to take a lot of turmeric water. So if you look at
which people are using a lot of turmeric water,
they are either those with a little bit of access
to WhatsApp or those who are dependent on
people who have access to WhatsApp. [...] At
the top [are people with] all ICT devices, and
at the bottom those who do not have access
to ICT devices, but they’re dependent on the
gatekeepers that are coming from the top. The
gatekeepers can be anyone. (interview, 2021)
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
A common theme across many of our key informant
interviews was that information disorder arises due
to polarization and bias; people are more likely
to believe information that already fits their preexisting beliefs.
MOTIVATIONS FOR SPREADING FALSE
INFORMATION
People’s motivations for spreading mis- or
disinformation are varied. Some are motivated
by ideology, while others are looking to monetize
clicks and will therefore promote even false content
to maximize clicks. Others spread misinformation
inadvertently, through ignorance, or even with
good intentions. For instance, Dr. N. Tamilselvi
noted that some people forward false appeals for
medical donations, genuinely believing them to
be real (interview, 2021). Qadaruddin Shishir from
AFP Fact Check describes motives for spreading as
follows:
State-sponsored actors spread this kind of
misinformation, opposition-sponsored actors
spread this kind of misinformation, and there
are some religious right-wing people who have
pages or groups on Facebook or YouTube and
they spread this disinformation. They know that
the [information is] false but they propagate it
on a regular basis. Then there are some other
actors, like financially motivated actors. They
have websites, Facebook pages, and YouTube
channels. They get ad revenue from clicks or
views. Some of them are journalists—[they do
not openly identify themselves as such, but the
nature of the] content [implies] that journalists
[could] be behind the production of this
content. They know that this is misinformation
or misleading information or outright false
information, but still they frequently spread
it just to attract readers to their websites and
channels to earn ad money. (interview, 2021)
People’s motivations for spreading misor disinformation are varied. Some are
motivated by ideology, while others are
looking to monetize clicks and will therefore
promote even false content to maximize
clicks. Others spread misinformation
inadvertently, through ignorance, or even
with good intentions.
Asia – 2 0 0
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents