is diverse and quite politicized, and that legal
solutions are approached in a superficial way.
Therefore, according to him, it is important to act
immediately, when bills are being discussed or even
earlier.
ARTICLE 19
Article 1910 is an international organization founded
in England that focuses on issues related to
freedom of expression and access to information.
The entity has offices in nine countries, two of
which are in Latin America (Brazil and Mexico).
Among the issues it addresses are the right to
protest, promotion of access to information, media
freedom, support for human rights defenders, and
the protection of digital rights.
On the issue of disinformation, Article 19 runs
programs to support independent media in the
most remote regions of Brazil. In the Amazon
region, it is acting to stimulate exchanges
between individuals and collectives that produce
and disseminate information based on the
demands of people in their territories. In 2022, a
campaign to support community communicators
in these locations will be launched.
The organization has also followed legislative
debates on the subject of disinformation, such as the
debates in Brazil around the bill that became known
as the “fake news bill.” The team also monitors the
production and dissemination of disinformation
aimed at institutions, which impact on democratic
processes. According to its digital rights
coordinator in Brazil, Paulo José Lara (interview,
August 2021), one of the difficulties experienced
is “fighting a process that is not institutional from
within institutions. A lot of what goes on originates
in small groups, small companies, groups that in
many places you can’t identify.”
CELE
CELE, which runs a legislative observatory on
freedom of expression in Latin America,11 is an
academic center for research on issues concerning
expression and information, linked to the University
of Palermo in Argentina. The center’s research is
aimed not only at producing knowledge but also
at stimulating public debate on these issues. CELE
created the legislative observatory to monitor
legislation, bills, and changes in the current legal
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
framework in order to analyze the possible impacts
on freedom of expression and access to information.
On the topic of disinformation, the observatory
gathers information about legislation on the
subject, and analyses some of it. The laws and legal
initiatives are evaluated according to the tripartite
test of the international framework on freedom of
expression: legality, necessity, and proportionality.
On its blog, the observatory publishes analyses of
legislation and projects, as well as analyses about
specific subjects. The project team prepared a
paper for the AlSur network on public officials and
disinformation, emphasizing the responsibility of
the actors that disseminate speeches containing
false content in the public sphere (AlSur 2021a).
CELE also participates in consultation processes
with international bodies. In the consultations
convened in 2021 by the UN Special Rapporteur on
Freedom of Opinion and Expression, Irene Khan, the
organization presented a report on disinformation
on the internet and the responses obtained from
three platforms: Facebook, Twitter, and Google
(CELE 2021).
ACCESS NOW
Access Now12 is an international organization
that works in Latin America and the Caribbean.
It covers a broad scope of issues, ranging from
internet access and functioning to data protection,
encryption, and freedom of expression. Access Now
contributes to each of these issues by developing
campaigns with other civil society organizations, as
well as supporting campaigns initiated by entities
in different regions and countries. The organization
participates in debates about international
guidelines and documents on these topics. In
the field of disinformation, it has contributed to
discussions and debates held by the European
Union (EU), the United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and
the UN Human Rights Council, and the UN Special
Rapporteur on Freedom of Opinion and Expression.
EFF
The EFF13 is one of the oldest organizations active in
the field of issues related to the internet. Founded
in the 1990s and based in the USA, the organization
works to strengthen human rights related to the
use of technologies, such as promoting freedom of
expression, combating surveillance and violence,
defending personal data protection, supporting
free technologies, and encouraging innovation.
On the issue of disinformation in Latin
America, the organization participated in the
Latin America and the Caribbean – 86