that the political authorities in their countries are
using legislation related to combating false news
in order to protect themselves from criticism and
from the circulation of information that may be
detrimental to them. Seven out of the eight lawyers
agreed that the criminalization of “false news” and
the imprisonment and prosecution of people who
publish it is not a solution that will limit information
disorder in society. Finally, all of the lawyers
agreed with the standpoint of local, regional, and
international human rights organizations, namely
that false news must be considered a civil and not
a criminal issue.
In assessing the legal status of the fight against
false and misleading information in their countries,
the eight lawyers view the legislation as contributing
more to the stifling of freedom of expression than
to the curbing of false news. They also believe that
the legislation directly targets freedom of opinion
and expression.
When asked about alternative civil solutions
to combat false and misleading information, the
lawyers suggested cancelling all criminal penalties
related to the freedom of publication and adopting
clear laws that set up civil retribution mechanisms
in publication-related crimes, with the ensuing
financial punishment. They also stressed the
importance of raising awareness among citizens;
supporting a digital culture of training users of
social networking sites to deal with information
critically; and allowing more freedom of opinion,
freedom of expression, and information exchange.
Tony Michael, a Lebanese lawyer specializing
in media law, expressed concern regarding the
escalating danger of mis- and disinformation
in the Arab world. He emphasized that “the
authorities control every part of the media, while
the media are either affiliated with the authorities
or are supportive of them.”
He pointed out that “Arab regimes can fabricate
information against the opposition or against those
demanding a change in government.” He said,
“Often, these regimes are not harmed by false news
but benefit from it by using it to suppress opposing
opinions.” Michael stressed that the spread of false
and misleading information is increased by a lack of
laws that guarantee the right to access information,
a lack of transparency, and the failure of official
administrations in Arab countries to provide
information and data (interview, July 2021).
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
In discussing solutions, Michael highlighted that
“laws in the Arab world must be revised to align
with international charters of freedom of opinion
and expression.” He added that the most effective
solution to the spread of mis- and disinformation
is “to educate citizens; to have the media bear the
responsibility for combating false and misleading
news; and to develop a participatory approach
towards this process, involving the state, civil
society, the media, and academics.” Moreover, he
argued, “Misinformation and disinformation cannot
be countered by laws, and any attempt to pass laws
to combat it in the Arab world is futile. We have
enough texts to intercept and block information.”
In the next section of this study, we answer the
following questions: Where is the Arab world today
in terms of the use of AI and technology to contribute
to the fight against mis- and disinformation? What
are the challenges that hinder progress in this field?
8. THE ROLE OF
TECHNOLOGY
AND ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE
The term “artificial intelligence” has recently
become a buzz word in the Arab world, especially
in journalism. There has been much talk about
the need to take advantage of AI techniques in
newsrooms, especially in news gathering, news
production, and news distribution, in addition to the
importance of automating fact checking to assist
human fact checkers.
Machine-learning algorithms are used by Google,
Facebook, Twitter, and other big tech companies to
deal with trolls, detect and remove bot accounts,
and proactively identify sensitive information.
Many fact-checking organizations around the
world are working to empower fact checkers with
the best tools. For example, Chequeabot is an
Argentinian tool, developed by Chequeado, that
automatically identifies claims in the media and
matches them with existing fact checks.31 The bot
helps perform everyday tasks for fact checkers,
many of whom are already using it in the newsroom.
Full Fact, developed in 2019, is an AI tool that can
detect and classify different types of claims and
can be used, for example, to help fact check party
manifestos.32
In some Arab countries, specifically Gulf
countries, interest in AI has increased recently:
• In 2017 the UAE became the first country to appoint a Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence,
Middle East and North Africa – 55