mosques are in fact teaching [people] how to go
and spread this among non-Muslims. This is very
deadly stuff, all of which was uncritically believed
and amplified by some broadcast media, who
ought to be much more responsible than that.
(interview, 2021)
The Muslim community was similarly scapegoated
in India during the pandemic (Murthy 2020).
Fear and uncertainty around the pandemic
also led to rumors regarding availability of care.
Dr. N. Tamilselvi, an independent fact checker from
India, recalled this phenomenon as follows:
As soon as this new government took over, [it
was] said that they had created 800 beds with
oxygen facilities for people in Chennai [at the
Chennai Nandambakkam Trade Center]. But,
unfortunately, an innocent mother’s number
was given and her son’s name was mentioned.
And when we tried to call this person [to ask]
whether he is responsible for getting admitted
here in the hospital, they literally cried. They said,
“Ma’am, I’ve been receiving at least 800 calls, I’m
tired of explaining this. I don’t even know how
my number got into this. We have no connection
to this trade center or oxygen facility or beds,
please remove our number.” (interview, 2021)
Furthermore, certain governments have tried to
conceal the extent and spread of the pandemic,
which included coercing those who contradicted
the official state narrative. Ruslan Myatiev, editor
of Turkmen.news, noted that the government of
Turkmenistan denies the existence of Covid-19
to this day. He added that Turkmenistan has
many economic and social problems, which the
government refuses to acknowledge, so denying
the reality of the Covid-19 pandemic is typical
(interview, 2021). Other examples abound. In the
early stages of the pandemic, the government of
Kazakhstan refused to admit that there were cases
of Covid-19 in the country and suppressed the true
extent of the infections. There are numerous cases
involving arrests of teachers, activists, doctors,
and ambulance drivers during this period (Toiken
2020; Utenova 2020). In Tajikistan, doctors and
public health officials are afraid to comment on
the magnitude of the infections in the country
(Yusufzoda 2021). This issue is certainly not limited
to Central Asia. For instance, the government of
India has ordered platforms to remove posts critical
of the government’s handling of the pandemic,
using mis- and disinformation as a rationale for this
(Krishnan 2021). Hence, it is clear that the Covid-19
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
pandemic has provided new opportunities for the
ecosystem of information disorder to thrive.
NATURAL DISASTERS
Instances of mis- and disinformation were observed
during the 2015 earthquake in Nepal (Nettikkara
2015). Injina Panthi noticed a similar phenomenon
during flooding and wildfires:
After the flood—the photo happened in
Sindhupalchok district of Nepal—and on social
media, they [were] posting old photos and
writing captions like, “Things are happening,
please wake up and help.” And so a photo that is
not from that place and that event is circulated.
We had a wildfire—two, three months before—
and then also, a photo from a foreign country
was circulated on social media, [with claims that
it was] from Nepal, and that due to the wildfires,
this much disaster and much loss is happening.
This kind of photo is mainly [asking people to
pray for victims].” (interview, 2021)
Relief scams circulating online have also been
observed (interview, Panthi, 2021).
HATE SPEECH
In many countries across Asia, members of ethnic
minorities, women, and members of the LGBTQI+
community have faced hate speech (see, for
example, Thaniago 2020). As noted in previous
sections, hate speech often coincides with other
forms of information disorder.
During election campaigns,
During election campaigns,
candidates can be targeted on
candidates can be targeted on
the basis of their religion or
the basis of their religion or
ethnicity. Pre-existing ethnic
ethnicity. Pre-existing ethnic
tensions are also harnessed by
tensions are also harnessed by
candidates to drum up support
candidates
and attract voters. Sometimes
and attract
this is connected to geopolitical
tensions, and those perceived
to be “foreign” are othered. Women and those
belonging to minority religions have also become
targets. Likewise, during the Covid-19 pandemic,
certain communities, often already marginalized
ones, have been scapegoated and labelled
“spreaders” of the disease.
For example, hate speech online and through
traditional media has been an ongoing problem in
Myanmar:
to drum up support
voters.
In Myanmar, communities have been disrupted,
traumatized and displaced due to the armed
conflicts between ethnic minorities armed
groups and the military governments as well as
Asia – 1 9 8
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents