ASEAN Regional Coalition to #StopDigitalDictatorship
TECH COMPANIES COMPLICIT OF DIGITAL
DICTATORSHIP: THE CASE OF TELEGRAM IN INDONESIA
Regarding Telegram specifically, the government imposed a temporary prohibition on
the messaging application in 2018 on the grounds that it facilitated communication
between terrorists. Following Telegram’s commitment to enhance content moderation
and establish a representative office in Indonesia, the prohibition was lifted. According
to a report by Nava Nuraniyah (2017), the underlying rationale for the blockade was not to suppress
extremism, as the statement asserts. On July 17, three days subsequent to the prohibition, Durov, the
CEO of Telegram, issued a statement wherein he admitted to his delayed reaction to the government’s
appeals to obstruct certain extremist channels and pledged to enhance collaboration with the government
by means of establishing a “direct line of communication.” However, it was not sufficient. To further
compel the lifting of the prohibition, the government has now mandated that Telegram establish a local
office in Indonesia, akin to the operations of Google, Yahoo, and Facebook. The level of concession that
Telegram will offer is yet to be determined. Eliminating Telegram access is, at best, a strategic manoeuvre
employed to align the operations of tech behemoths with governmental regulations.124
PANDEMIC POLITICS: COVID-19
IMPACT ON ONLINE ACTIVITIES
The COVID-19 pandemic has allowed authorities to
The pandemic allowed authorities to limit freedom
constrict civic space in the country and freedom of
of speech excessively in the country. In 2020, a
expression was limited excessively. Social media
university professor said that hackers released
users who criticised the government’s handling
images of him and a woman they claimed to be his
of COVID-19 have been charged under ITE Law
mistress on his Twitter page after he criticised the
for allegedly spreading disinformation about the
government’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic.127
COVID-19 pandemic. In the two-year window between
Several other organisations alleged that hackers
January 2020 and 2022, authorities have opened
erased content from their websites, while media
investigation into and prosecuted 767 pandemic-
outlets and civil society organisations, including
related disinformation cases.125 Police order No.
Tempo, Tirto.id, and the Centre for Indonesia’s
ST/1100/IV/HUK.7.1.2020 came into force in April
Strategic Development Initiatives (CISDI), were
2020, giving police emergency powers to conduct
hacked after posting articles criticising the pandemic
“cyber patrols” and monitor online discussions
management.128 In another Article 28(2) case, Wira
around COVID-19, the government’s handling of it,
Pratama, a resident of Riau Islands off the coast
and any other information surrounding this topic.126
of Sumatra, was prosecuted for uploading on his
personal Facebook account a meme of President
98
Dawn of Digital Dictatorship: Weaponizing the Law Against Online Speech in Southeast Asia