ASEAN Regional Coalition to #StopDigitalDictatorship
Everybody is At Risk of Being a Target
of the Government
In 2020, SAFEnet documented 22 cases of internet
support the longstanding observation of activists
users being charged with Article 27(3) of the ITE
and HRDs that the ITE Law is routinely misused to
Law. An additional 17 were reported in 2021.54
criminalise hundreds of people simply for exercising
Data gathered by Amnesty International Indonesia,
their right to freedom of expression online.58 A 2023
conversely, shows that the ITE Law was used
report by FORUM-ASIA and KontraS shows a new
against approximately 81 people from January 2020
pattern in officials’ efforts to suppress criticism:
to October 2021, most of whom were accused of
Cease-and-Desist letters. Started in 2021, this type
defamation.55 Between January 2019 and December
of action consists of public officials redacting letters
2022, Amnesty International Indonesia documented
in which they fill in for lawsuits against activists,
that at least 1,021 human rights defenders faced
often citing defamation, insults, or fake news. The
prosecution, arrests, attacks, and threats, under the
approach often ends in criminalisation, with the
defamation article in ITE Law.56 SAFEnet has also
accused facing charges and further pressure from
highlighted a concerning trend, reporting a total of
the government to cease their activism. This also
89 cases of criminalisation related to these articles
occurred in Haris Azhar and Fatia Maulidiyanti’s
from January to October 2023.57 These findings
cases detailed below.59
“
Despite by the end of 2023 the ITE Law having
been amended or revised twice, the defamation and
blasphemy articles, which have often been misused
to silence criticism and repress press freedom, are still
maintained. In fact, now new articles have been added,
such as articles prohibiting disinformation and excessive
authority to cut off Internet access, making the ITE Law
even more dangerous for the future of Internet freedom
and democracy in Indonesia. It is easy to imagine the
number of judicial harassment cases increasing and
online censorship becoming more rampant.
- Damar Juniarto, Executive Director of SAFEnet 2018-2023 and Advisor of
SAFEnet
88
Dawn of Digital Dictatorship: Weaponizing the Law Against Online Speech in Southeast Asia