ASEAN Regional Coalition to #StopDigitalDictatorship
2. Indonesia
DIGITAL SPACE & ONLINE
FREEDOM STATUS OF THE
COUNTRY
DEMOCRATIC STATUS
OF THE COUNTRY
YEAR
(according to the Freedom
In The World index)
PRESS & MEDIA FREEDOM
STATUS OF THE COUNTRY
(Digital Space Status)
(according to the World’s Press
Freedom Index)
2020
61/100
49/100
119/180 (63,18)
2021
59/100
48/100
113/180 (62,6)
2022
59/100
49/100
117/180 (49,27)
2023
58/100
47/100
108/180 (54,83)
(Partly
PARTLYFree)
FREE
(Partly
PARTLYFree)
FREE
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
Scores
100-70
Difficult
DIFFICULT
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
FREE
Difficult
DIFFICULT
Difficult
DIFFICULT
(Partly
Free)
PARTLY FREE
PARTLY FREE
Scores
69-40
Difficult
DIFFICULT
NOT FREE
Scores
39-0
GOOD
SATISFACTORY
PROBLEMATIC
DIFFICULT
VERY SERIOUS
85–100 points
75–85 points
65–75 points
45–65 points
0–45 points
Fig. 2.1: Summary of freedom ratings for the Indonesia, 2020-2023.1
2.1 Legal Framework
Freedom of Expression: Guaranteed yet
Illegitimately Restricted
widely disseminating his/her beliefs, orally or in
In Indonesia, the right to freedom of expression and
public interest and nation’s unity”. Additionally,
speech is guaranteed by Articles 28, 28E, and 28F
Article 25 guarantees that “every person has the
of the 1945 Constitution. These provisions stipulate
right to express opinion in public, and this includes
that individuals are entitled to express themselves
the right to strike, in accordance with the provisions
both verbally and in writing, and to communicate
of legislation”.3 The ratification of the International
and search for, receive, possess, store, process and
Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 2006 also
transmit information using all channels available.
2
enhanced the protection of freedom of expression in
Furthermore, Law Number 39 of 1999 on Human
Indonesia.4 These pivotal advancements underscore
Rights emphasises guarantees and protection for
the heightened normative assurance for the freedom
freedom of opinion. Article 23 (2) ensures that
of expression in the country. Indonesia takes pride in
“every person is free from holding, expressing and
its democratic transformation since the downfall of the
72
writing through printed or electronic media, taking
into consideration religious values, morals, order,
Dawn of Digital Dictatorship: Weaponizing the Law Against Online Speech in Southeast Asia