ASEAN Regional Coalition to #StopDigitalDictatorship
the attacks were linked to the Department of Science
the narrative that the University of the Philippines
and Technology of the Philippine military.
is a “breeding ground” for enemies of the state.60
54
The
Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-PH) in
the Department of Information and Communications
Technology (DICT) also confirmed that an internet
protocol address associated with cyberattacks
against various alternative media outlets was linked
to the Department of Science and Technology and
the military.55 The DICT stated that the allegations
Journalists are among those who often get redtagged publicly on social media. In April 2020, a
photo of female journalists conducting a media
safety training session from 2013 surfaced on
several platforms. The photo’s caption claimed that
one of the photographed women, who works with
were “unfounded and patently false.”56
ABS-CBN broadcasting network, was involved in
The news websites Rappler and ABS-CBN, as well as
the Butuan City police posted a photo that named
websites Vera Files, GMA News and CNN Philippines,
several organisations as communist groups on
have all experienced several technical attacks.
57
Facebook, while other law enforcement authorities
A hacking group called Pinoy Vendetta claimed
in the city of Baguio accused a handful of left-wing
responsibility for these attacks, as well as others
groups of being terrorists on Twitter.62 Under the
conducted on websites of opposition senators,
Duterte administration, red-tagging was a common
the Philippine Senate and left-leaning groups. A
form of harassment and intimidation, and it appears
spokesperson of the National Task Force to End
to continue under the current president, Ferdinand
Local Communist Armed Conflict (NTF-ELCAC),
Marcos Jr. Red-tagging is especially dangerous
Lorraine Badoy, praised the hackers for being able
for Indigenous activists because, having already
to put down websites of the political left. Despite
reduced visibility, red-tagging further marginalised
this, the NTF-ELCAC and Pinoy Vendetta have both
Indigenous peoples by labelling them as terrorists
consistently denied collusion.
Lorraine Badoy
or communists. However, red-tagging can happen
has likewise accused Rappler of being “an ally
to anyone part of the opposition and, perhaps its
and mouthpiece” of the Communist Party of the
most dangerous trait is that it often is a precursor for
Philippines, New People’s Army and the National
violent attacks.63 There was hope for improvement
Democratic Front of the Philippines, in addition to
in 2022 when the now ex-National Security Advisor,
stating that Facebook’s fact-checkers are “liars and
Clarita Carlos, declared she would want to stop this
unethical journalists” like Maria Ressa and Rappler.
oppressive tactic.64 That quickly changed only seven
58
local communist groups.61 In a different incident,
59
Red-Tagging of Activists and Critics
In addition to lawsuits and cyberattacks, individuals
in the country are targeted by state agencies through
the creation of false narratives online. In January
2021, the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP)
listed through a Facebook post several names of
University of the Philippines alumni, claiming that
they were joiners of the New People’s Army and had
been killed or captured. The AFP has since taken
months into her role, when, in her own words, was
forced out by other “forces.”65 She was replaced by
retired general Eduardo Año, who did not address the
red-tagging issue so far. This is even more concerning
because he is allegedly involved in the abduction
of activist Jonas Burgos in April 2007 who has
officially been ruled as an enforced disappearance
authored by the military, and was also chief-of-staff
of the Armed Forces of Philippines during Duterte’s
authoritarian regime.66
down the post, but it has been circulated around
by other Facebook pages. In a statement, the NUJP
underscored that the AFP was motivated to push
226
Dawn of Digital Dictatorship: Weaponizing the Law Against Online Speech in Southeast Asia
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents