ASEAN Regional Coalition to #StopDigitalDictatorship
Thousands of displaced Rohingya are currently
If Southeast Asian governments truly wanted to
seeking refuge on the coasts of Indonesia,
demonstrate their commitment to human rights,
Thailand
Myanmar.
they would, at very least, implement effective
Indonesia, like Thailand and Malaysia, has not
remedy measures to handle cases of human
signed the 1951 United Nations Convention on
rights abuses, including implementing procedural
Refugees, which sets out legal protections, and
safeguards and independent oversight. Right
is therefore under no legal obligation to accept
now, no Southeast Asian government has these
them. What’s more, these Rohingya face hostility
systems in place at an adequate level. For example,
from the local population. It is risky enough to be
Cambodia, Malaysia, Myanmar, Singapore, and
a vocal HRD of any kind in Southeast Asia; HRDs
Vietnam have no specific legislation to protect
with intersectional marginalised identities are at
people from Strategic Lawsuits Against Public
an even greater risk, as the oppressive bodies will
Participation (SLAPP), at all. Lao PDR does not
intentionally use hateful, discriminatory language
even recognise human rights defenders, and
and other forms of violence against them.
does not have any anti-SLAPP measures in place.
and
Malaysia,
fleeing
10
It is paradoxical for Southeast Asian governments
to claim that they are champions of human rights
and freedom, while allowing these intense abuses
to happen against people expressing themselves
freely online and offline. There is no need for such
pretence while our democracies are clearly under
attack in Southeast Asia. According to Freedom
House’s methodology, and as indicated in each
Indonesia, Philippines, and Thailand are among
the few countries who have some anti-SLAPP
provisions; however, they are either insufficient,
very limited (for example, in the case of the
Philippines where provisions are only available
regarding environmental cases), or difficult to put
into practice because of the inefficient judicial
systems in place.
of our Thematic Report chapters, all except four
All the above are very concerning symptoms
of the Southeast Asian nations mentioned in our
of digital dictatorship. Evidently, oppressive
Report were considered ‘authoritarian’ (‘not free’)
governments across Southeast Asia recognise
states in 2023. The only four that were considered
the power of the internet, surveillance technology,
‘semi-authoritarian’ (‘partly free’) were Singapore,
and Artificial Intelligence, and have abused them
Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines; these
for their own gain. If digital freedoms are under
three were considered ‘semi-authoritarian.’ Thus,
threat, then human rights are under threat. This is
it will undeniably take time to fully revolutionise
poignantly demonstrated in the way that Freedom
outdated and harmful systemic structures; fixing
House’s ‘Freedom on the Net’ (FOTN) and ‘Freedom
these complex systems will not happen overnight.
in the World’ (FITW) reports have both depicted
However, the complexity of these structures is
declining trends in societal freedoms.
11
no excuse for denying people of human rights.
10. Associated Press News, As more Rohingya arrive by boat, Indonesia asks the international community to share its burden, (December 12,
2023), available at: https://apnews.com/article/indonesia-myanmar-refugees-rohingya-6a4ab1304cf7e2b6c5fa1b8a456d9aca; Euronews with
AFP, Rohingya refugees forcibly evicted by students in Indonesia, (27 December, 2023), available at: https://www.euronews. com/2023/12/27/
rohingya-refugees-forcibly-evicted-by-students-in-indonesia.
11. Freedom House, Countries and Territories, (last updated 2023), available at: https://freedomhouse.org/ countries/freedom-world/scores.;
Freedom House, Freedom in the World Research Methodology, (last updated 2023), available at: https://freedomhouse. org/reports/freedomworld/freedom-world-research-methodology.
20
Dawn of Digital Dictatorship: Weaponizing the Law Against Online Speech in Southeast Asia