Contd. Pakistan and Geedge
Geedge Platforms on Old Hardware and Troubling Privacy Concerns
In their new report Shadows of Control, Amnesty International’s Security Lab writes that
one of the most important revelations from the leak of documents from Geedge Networks
is “how technologies from different suppliers can be inter-dependent and repurposed to
work together.”53 In other words, the system established by Sandvine became a foundation,
and when their contract not renewed, Geedge was able to repurpose Sandvine’s hardware
to run the Geedge operating system. Amnesty found a document showing the design of the
WMS, from July 20, 2023, running Geedge’s TSG platform on repurposed Sandvine
hardware.54
While built on repurposed hardware, a report in Al Jazeera hints at how much the Geedge
system might have cost: officials who spoke to the Qatari news broadcasters on condition
of anonymity said that a new Chinese system from an unnamed supplier would cost
Pakistan between 20 to 30 billion rupees ($72 million to $107 million), and was responsible
for the slower internet speeds and full-on shutdowns reported by users in the second half
of 2024.55
The Geedge system can capture more than metadata. If a connection is unencrypted, the
system will also opportunistically capture the content. Amnesty International found one
support ticket in Geedge’s Jira system with the full content of two emails including
attachments and the e-mail password, which was intercepted by TSG on an unencrypted
connection to an email server.56
It is concerning that sensitive user data is included in a support ticket for a third-party
service provider, and that this sensitive data was part of a leak. To further illustrate the
troubling issues of user data and privacy within the Pakistan case, as Amnesty points out,
since 2015 every new SIM card issued to a mobile subscriber in the country must be
registered to a particular user and linked to biometrics including fingerprints that are
registered via the National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA). People need a
NADRA profile to access basic services like healthcare, banking, and education. The
NADRA profile also links to other databases, like voter registration and tax records, which
combined create a comprehensive record on every citizen. 57 A core feature of Geedge’s
Sanity Directory component is attributing traffic to a specific SIM card. This enables, not
only mass surveillance, but highly targeted micro-surveillance on specific individuals in
Pakistan and other countries Geedge operates.