Tech company responses and the UNGP
ARTICLE 19
authoritarian contexts and adopting risk management strategies in response. Some
companies have provided next to no information about particular human rights
controversies. Bing has disclosed very little information about how it responds to Chinese
censorship demands, for example. In Myanmar, beyond initial public announcements about
actions taken to ban military accounts, most companies have not released detailed updates
about how they are responding to ongoing military-inspired harmful speech on their
platforms.
Lack of country-specific human rights due diligence
Third, tech companies should engage in regular, country-specific human rights due
diligence. The case studies in this report show that there is little evidence that such due
diligence is being undertaken. As outlined in the UNGPs, this should be an ongoing exercise
with multiple steps, including identifying and assessing impacts, acting to prevent and
mitigate risks, tracking the effectiveness of risk mitigation, and appropriate communication
of performance.231
Most tech companies covered in this report do not appear to be engaged in ongoing human
rights due diligence specific to China, Vietnam, or Myanmar, or at least they do not publicise
it. Even where companies have engaged in due diligence, it has not been sufficiently
comprehensive and ongoing. Telenor commissioned a human rights impact assessment
before it entered Myanmar in 2014 but seemingly failed to maintain adequate ongoing
assessments, including advanced planning for a responsible exit.232 An example of a flawed
approach to human rights impact assessments in the region is given in the box below.
Overall, tech companies operating in authoritarian countries in Asia need to devote much
more leadership, planning, and resources to human rights due diligence.
____________________________________________
231
B-Tech, Taking Action to Address Human Rights: Risks Related to End-Use, OHCHR, September 2020,
p. 2 (providing a graphical summary).
232 Telenor, Human Rights in Myanmar. Telenor Myanmar did release annual ‘sustainability briefings’.
55