This is not dissimilar to the “Aadhar” biometric scheme in India, which
was widely decried by activists and rights defenders as carrying
huge risks for the marginalized26 and the poor27. Aadhar is a unique
identification system based on biometric and demographic data that
was integrated with the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment
Guarantee Act (MGNREGA). The government mandated that wages
under MGNREGA would only be paid to workers whose bank
accounts are linked with their Aadhaar numbers. Warnings about mass
surveillance28 followed the introduction of Aadhar, but it has not slowed
down the government’s policy. The Aadhar-based system facilitates racial
profiling by disproportionately impacting communities that struggle with
documentation, leading to their exclusion from welfare benefits.
DEBTS AND GEOPOLITICAL
MANEUVERING
Across South Asia, societies are falling into severe states of economic
crisis, often combined with major political upheaval. In Pakistan,29
Bangladesh30 and Sri Lanka,31 varying states of economic collapse have
led to International Monetary Fund interventions, starting in about 2019.
Much has been written about exploitation, traps, and violence of debt
deals. However, debt arrangements are not only tools of economic
exploitation, they are strategic instruments that allow states to maneuver
within the global power dynamics.32 Several countries in the region find
themselves in debt arrangements with China. Experts have pointed out
that “China has adopted ‘debt trap diplomacy’ as part of an economic
expansionist approach to expand its influence around the world in
26
rnagarwala, T. (2024). How Aadhaar is strangling MGNREGA in a Maharashtra district and pushing workers to
migrate. Scroll.in. https://scroll.in/article/1062358/how-aadhaar-is-strangling-mgnrega-in-a-maharashtra-district-and-pushing-workers-to-migrate
27
Yadav, A. (2016). Six months after Rajasthan introduced it, only 45% beneficiaries used Aadhaar at ration shops.
Scroll.in. https://scroll.in/article/809661/six-months-after-rajasthan-introduced-aadhaar-at-ration-shops-only-45-beneficiaries-accessed-food
28
Basu, S. & Malik, R. (2017). India’s dodgy mass surveillance project should concern us all. Wired. https://www.
wired.com/story/india-aadhaar-biometrics-privacy/#:~:text=India%20is%20undertaking%20the%20world’s,project%20
will%20have%20catastrophic%20consequences
29
Ahmed, M. (2024). Pakistan and IMF reach preliminary deal to release $1.1 billion from bailout fund, IMF says. AP
News. https://apnews.com/article/pakistan-imf-preliminary-deal-bailout-fund-2160022481d933190a301582eb19f12a
30
Ruma, P. (2023). IMF board clears first review of Bangladesh’s $4.7 billion bailout. Reuters. https://www.reuters.
com/world/asia-pacific/imf-board-clears-first-review-bangladeshs-47-billion-bailout-2023-12-12/
31
Francis, K. (2023). Sri Lanka will get the second tranche of a much-need bailout package from the IMF. AP News.
https://apnews.com/article/sri-lanka-imf-economic-crisis-bailout-tranche-4ef85320ad1b900fb3e4bd21014bd3aa
32
Sial, F., Jafri, J., & Khaliq, A. (2023). Pakistan, China and the structures of debt distress: Resisting Bretton Woods.
Development and Change. https://doi.org/10.1111/dech.12798
19