ABOUT the research
A few years ago, simply displaying a
picture of the opposition politician
in a Burmese newspaper would risk
arrest and imprisonment
Ecosystems
in Political Transition
7 Day News Journal - Kyaik Hto - Zay Yar Mon Ward
through formal edicts, but counter intuitively, also
through formal and less formal relationships that
developed between soldiers and citizens in areas where
they lived in close contact for decades. The ethnic
armies (often highly mobile) were also key sources of
information for citizens in conflict zones. Meanwhile
state radio was the most accessible media source to all
parties – a ubiquitous kind of information “wallpaper”
common to all. Such a situation raises intriguing
questions about citizen attitudes towards choice,
agency and trust in ecosystems where information has
traditionally been owned and transmitted primarily
by those vested with some sort of authority.
Myanmar Media Landscape 2012-2014
Myanmar’s media landscape has changed dramatically
in the last two years since the 2010 election, the
release of Aung San Suu Kyi from house arrest and the
commencement of the current government-managed
reform process. A few years ago, simply displaying
a picture of the opposition politician in a Burmese
newspaper or on the streets of Yangon would risk arrest
and imprisonment. Foreign news sources such as the
BBC and Radio Free Asia (RFA), and Burmese exile
media including the Democratic Voice of Burma (DVB),
The Irrawaddy, and Mizzima News, were outright
banned. Today, such restrictions on media access no
longer exist. Importantly, pre-publication censorship
of all media has been abolished. In June 2011, the
Myanmar government began easing media control by
allowing non-political newspapers to publish without
first submitting all articles to the Press Scrutiny and
Registration Division (PSRD), the Orwellian-sounding
government censorship bureau. By August 2012, the
government had announced the end to prior censorship
for all publications, a practice that began in 1964 during
the early days of General Ne Win’s military regime.
Publishers of exiled media, including Mizzima, DVB,
and Irrawaddy, have now officially entered Myanmar
and set up bureaus in Yangon. In April, for the first time
since the 1960s, the government began allowing private
daily newspapers to print.
Media choices in Myanmar are growing quickly
and offer the prospect of greater choice and range
of viewpoints, but remain primarily defined by the
mainstream media that vary in accessibility and
quality. Newspapers have been proliferating in
the cities while new television programs, driven
particularly by satellite TV services, have expanded the
range of content and programming available within
the country. These range from rich political discussion
via DVB-Burmese to a variety of entertainment,
including popular Burmese and Korean soap operas
and even Myanmar Idol, a Burmese version of the
popular music competition.
However, despite Myanmar’s expanding media
choices, most options remain limited to urban centers
and entrenched in old interests. According to a report
from Reporters Without Borders, “There are more
than 300 newspapers in Burma, of which around 100
are based in and around Rangoon and only about 30
cover the news.”24 Moreover, according to the NLD
elder statesman Win Tin, “Only 25 percent of the
newspapers are independent, that is to say, entirely
financed by the private sector. The other 75 percent
are linked to military leaders.”25
Similarly, in TV and radio, the stations with the
most extensive reach and popularity remain in the
government’s hands—state-run Nay Pyi Daw Myanmar
Radio National Service (Nay Pyi Daw Myanma Ah-Than)
has served as a government mouthpiece and had little
in the way of entertainment programs, while popular
MRTV is a joint venture between the government and
the private firm Forever Group Ltd. Still, even these are
24 Reporters Without Borders,
“Burmese Media Spring” (December 2012).
25
Ibid.
16
INFORMATION ECOSYSTEMS in transition: a case study from myanmar
part one: rese arch findings
evolving. In Mon State, Nay Pyi Daw Myanmar Radio
broadcasts Mon language programs, which have proved
popular with many respondents, while MRTV does
not have the appearance of being government-owned,
running everything from music and food programming
to game shows.
For Internet, three providers exist in Myanmar: Red
Link Communications, Sky Net MPS, and Yatanarpon
Teleport. All three work under the regulation of stateowned Myanmar Posts and Telecommunications
(MPT), which controls all aspects of Myanmar’s
communications sector, including landlines, street
phone kiosks, and mobile phones. At the current time,
connecting to the Internet outside of Internet cafes
is beyond the financial reach of most of Myanmar’s
citizens and the country still has one of the lowest
degrees of internet penetration in the world: 1-2%.
Increased Access Does Not
Necessarily Mean Better Informed
It is intuitive to think that an overall increase in the
supply of media inputs channeled to local and national
information ecosystems will result in all citizens
becoming “better informed.” Similar assumptions
lie behind Communication for Development
approaches that inject public service messages into
target communities. There is, however, a body of
evidence that suggests these assumptions are not
necessarily well founded: that both media content and
C4D messages can easily miss their mark, and that
unintended consequences can ensue. For those who
17
how to inform, empower, and impact communities
INFORMATION ECOSYSTEMS in transition: a case study from myanmar
how to inform, empower, and impact communities
PART ONE: RESEARCH FINDINGS