Exploring the Nexus between Technologies
and Human Rights
24
corporations. In almost all focus groups the threat of China was mentioned, not only
in light of Chinese surveillance technologies and ideologies that are being pushed to
authoritarian governments within the region, but also scepticism that Southeast Asian
governments would have the abilities to protect their citizens’ data against external
surveillance by China.
At the national level, respondents offered insights of increased collection of citizen data
by the state, through “objectifying the individual with numbers, whereby sometimes
the numbers are more important than the individual”, as put by a respondent. In the
Philippines, the law to put in mandate the universal adoption of a national identification
system is highly debated. On one hand, it provides the convenience of administering
state services, but on the other hand a log is kept of where the ID holder has used the
card, thus collecting and anchoring one’s digital trail to one ID number. Advocates voiced
their scepticism of the ability of the government to prevent data breaches. In the Thai
focus group, a respondent opined that much of the state procurement of systems and
technologies for mass collection of citizen data is vendor-driven, which is to say that
the data is collected without any immediate goal and is not done in a critical manner.
In Malaysia, concern was expressed on the imminent inclusion of one’s mobile phone
number into the information of one’s national ID, which links different datasets by
default, making it even easier to form a digital profile of the individual.
Access to the Digital
About 60% of Southeast Asia’s population is connected to the Internet, with uneven
access across the region, as shown in Table 6. The top four countries of Brunei,
Singapore, Thailand, and Malaysia have more than 80% of their populations online,
while the bottom three of Laos, Myanmar, and Timor Leste have only a third of their
populations online. These figures have to be considered against the population size, as
Indonesia with its vast population has more than 300 times the number of Internet users
in Brunei, even if its Internet penetration is only 53.2%. Respondents pointed out that
access is not only about basic infrastructural access but also about quality of service and
affordability, as well as literacy in how to maximise the access to connectivity.