“organized army of far-right trolls” which belongs to the BJP (Mackintosh & Gupta, 2020).
Amnesty International (2020) conducted research into online harassment and found that one in
every seven tweets mentioning women politicians in India was ‘problematic’ or ‘abusive,’ and
that one in every five problematic tweets was sexist or misogynistic. While both parties deny
supporting online trolls, these accounts are often aligned with party agendas and the leaders
provide tacit support. For example, Prime Minister Modi follows known troll accounts on
Twitter, and drew criticism for hosting one hundred and fifty social media influencers at his
residence in 2015, many of whom used sexual slurs to harass women online (Safi, 2018).
Manipulated Content
Doctored photos and videos circulate widely on social media, as both a means of political
persuasion and to attack opponents. This is particularly concerning as senior politicians often
share these images from personal accounts. For example, an edited video purported to show
INC leader for East Uttar Pradesh Priyanka Gandhi teaching children abusive political slogans
was shared by Smriti Irani, a serving cabinet minister for the BJP. However, the full unedited
video reveals that Gandhi can be seen telling the children to stop using abusive language
(@DFRLab, 2019). Similarly, Divya Spandana, director of social media and communications
for the INC, shared a doctored photo of Prime Minister Modi that drew a comparison with
Adolf Hitler (Sidharth, 2019).
A significant technological development has been the first use of a deepfake video as part of
an Indian election campaign. Ahead of the legislative assembly elections in Delhi, on 7
February 2020, two deepfake videos of BJP President Manoj Tiwari criticising the Delhi
government were circulated on WhatsApp (Christopher, 2020). This was organised by the
Delhi BJP IT Cell and political communications firm The Ideaz Factory. It utilised deepfake
technology to create a video in which the politician speaks a local Hindi dialect—Haryanvi.
Concerns about the manipulative potential for deepfakes have grown, but this particular
application of deepfakes is part of a campaign to reach different linguistic voter bases. Neelkant
Bakshi, of the BJP Delhi IT cell, said the deepfakes were distributed to 5,800 WhatsApp groups
in Delhi, reaching fifteen million people (Christopher, 2020). Deepfakes have previously been
used for manipulated pornographic content. India’s youngest parliamentarian, Chandrani
Murmu, was subject to her face being superimposed onto an obscene video ahead of her
election in 2019 (Mackintosh & Gupta, 2020).
Table 2: Observed Strategies, Tools and Techniques of Social Media Manipulation in
India
Account Types Messaging and Valence
Content
and Platforms
Communication
Strategies
Human, Fake,
Automated
Facebook pages & ads,
Facebook,
disinformation &
Instagram, Twitter,
misinformation websites,
WhatsApp, NaMo
memes, doctored videos,
WhatsApp groups,
deepfakes, amplification
Source: Authors’ evaluations based on data collected. Blank spaces indicate no evidence was found.
180
Pro-Party Messages, Attacks
on Opposition, Polarization
Strategies, Trolling and
Harassment