A/HRC/39/CRP.2
victim, the soldier responsible was slapped 10 times and compensation of 200,000 Kyat
provided to a male family member of the victim. 891
402. Due to the lack of cooperation from the Government of Myanmar, the Mission did not
have access to official information on prosecutions against members of the Tatmadaw for
violations. However, the Mission is aware that in a small number of cases, members of the
Tatmadaw have been prosecuted for violations including killings and sexual violence. For
example, in relation to the killing of three IDPs in Mansi Township, Kachin State in May
2017, a military tribunal sentenced six Tatmadaw soldiers to 10 years’ imprisonment in
January 2018.892 The Mission is also aware of a case of a child who was raped in Kachin
State where a soldier was sentenced to 10 years in prison with hard labour. 893 However,
investigations and prosecutions appear to be limited to a small number of often high-profile
cases. The default approach is to deny Tatmadaw responsibility, dismiss the complainant,
and in some cases threatening prosecution against anyone alleging Tatmadaw involvement
in the incident, and only when these approaches fail to deflect attention, to undertake some
form of investigation which generally does not comply with international investigative
standards.894
403. For example, the Tatmadaw has threatened legal action in relation to the killings of
the volunteer teachers named Maran Lu Ra and Tangbau Hkawn Nan Tsin in Shan State on
19 January 2015, and there were serious concerns about the investigation methods. 895 A
similar pattern can be seen in incidents of arrest, for example in the case of Dumdaw Nawng
Lat and Langjaw Gam Seng in Monekoe, Muse Township, Shan State, where the Presidential
spokesperson denied on 10 January 2017 they were held by the Tatmadaw, but it later
transpired that they had in fact been detained in a military base from 24 December 2016. 896
Credible information received on the killing of seven individuals in Mong Yaw, Shan State
in June 2016 indicates that following an incident where witnesses saw two individuals being
shot by the Tatmadaw after they ignored an order to stop at a checkpoint, and five other
individuals being detained near their farm land and not returning, the military ordered
villagers not to leave their village for three days. 897 When villagers were able to go back to
their farms, the bodies of the seven individuals were found in two sites. On 2 July 2016, the
Myawaddy military-owned newspaper, stated that “rumours on social media that Tatmadaw
had killed seven civilians, which were not true,” continuing that two of the individuals were
TNLA members and the other five bodies had been found by troops during “area
clearance.”898 However, later a Tatmadaw senior general reportedly admitted publically that
five villagers were killed by the Tatmadaw during an interrogation,899 and in September 2016,
seven soldiers were reportedly sentenced to five years in prison with hard labour for the
killings.900 It does not appear further investigations have been conducted into the two
individuals allegedly killed at the checkpoint.
404. The Mission also received credible information indicating that even when cases are
brought before authorities, the process is often flawed. For example, a lawyer who has taken
up several cases against the Tatmadaw identified a number of issues related to the functioning
of courts in their experience:
When cases are tried by a military court, the charges are often not what is expected
because the military code is different. For example, in a case of sexual violence, there
is no such charge, so a perpetrator was sentenced instead for intoxication during
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
98
PI-110.
A/HRC/37/70, para. 36.
PI-037.
See chapter X: Impunity and accountability.
See this chapter, section A.4: Sexual and gender-based violence.
See this chapter, section A.5: Arbitrary deprivation of liberty and enforced disappearance.
K-076.21.
Article on file with the Mission.
W. Lone, “In rare move, Myanmar military admits soldiers killed five villagers” (Reuters, 20 July
2016).
Frontier Myanmar, “Tatmadaw soldiers jailed for killing Mong Yaw villagers” (16 September 2016).