The Platform Question: Power, Accountability and Global South
The Platform Question: Power, Accountability and Global South
CHAPTER 12
Platform Accountability:
A Translation Experiment with Words,
Meanings and People
By Dr. Raina Ghosh
As the concluding chapter of this anthology that reflects
upon the themes of platforms, power, accountability, and
the Global South, this essay weaves together threads of the
preceding discussions, connecting facets of regulation, labour,
and algorithmic control to the very language of responsibility
itself. The chapter attempts at showing how “platform
accountability” transforms, travels, and resists translation
across cultures, revealing new ways to imagine digital justice
from the Global South.
The Global Gathering, held from September 8th to 10th in
Portugal, brought together a gamut of progressive techies,
activists, cyber lawyers, digital rights defenders, researchers,
and civil society organisations from around the world to explore
questions of digital rights, platform governance, and collective
action. Organised by Team CommUNITY, the gathering created
a space for the cross-pollination of ideas across scales and
geographies, offering a rare opportunity for people working
on similar challenges in different contexts to meet, learn, and
strategise together.
At the Gathering, ARISE, supported by the DEF Secretariat,
hosted a booth with a deceptively simple exercise. We asked
participants passing through to write on small, colourful sticky
notes - “platform accountability” in their own language, or
in their mother tongue, or to think about the word closest
to it. Some paused, puzzled by the challenge of translation.
Others wrote quickly, confidently. A few engaged in animated
discussions about whether a direct equivalent even existed
in their language. Over a period of 2 hours, contributions
accumulated on our table – bringing a polyphonic vista that
included scripts such as Arabic, Sinhalese, Bengali, Spanish,
alongside Setswana, Filipino, French, and many more.
150
Platform Accountability: A Translation Experiment with Words, Meanings and People
The emergent
collection of
translations
revealed something
more profound for
all of us to ponder
- a kaleidoscope
of meanings, each
note reflecting a
different cultural
understanding
of responsibility,
power, and
social bonds. The
exercise, in fact,
became a live
ethnography of
how communities
across geographies
conceptualise
the relationship
between those who
hold power and
those affected by it.
Platform Accountability: A Translation Experiment with Words, Meanings and People
151
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents