to clarify false information on matters of public
interest (Lee 2017). In 2018, the Myanmar Ministry of
Communication and Transportation created a social
media monitoring team (Situ 2018). In 2017, the
MCMC in Malaysia launched an online portal called
Sebenarnya.11 The website contains fact checks and
enables the public to verify news (Hassan 2017).
The government of Vietnam launched its Anti-Fake
News Center in January 2021 (Diep 2021). The army
of Vietnam also has an online information warfare
unit called Force 47, which
consists of thousands of soldiers who, in addition
to their normal duties, are tasked with setting up,
moderating and posting on pro-state Facebook
groups, to correct “wrong views” online. According to a Reuters review of provincial-level state
media reports and broadcasts by the army’s official television station, Force 47 has since its inception in 2016 set up hundreds of Facebook groups
and pages, and published thousands of pro-government articles and posts. (Pearson 2021)
The Indonesian Ministry of Information and
Communication Technologies (Kominfo) has
undertaken a variety of initiatives on mis- and
disinformation. This includes a war room which uses
both humans and AI tools to detect content (Basu
and Tay 2020). A task force to deal with “fake news”
was also created in Laos in 2021 (Thanabouasy 2021).
Sri Lanka’s Media Center for National Development
also contains a fact-checking unit. This department
falls under the Ministry of Mass Media.
There has been some criticism of state-backed
task forces. For example, Facebook took the
following actions against Force 47 in Vietnam:
After being approached by Reuters this week, a
Facebook source said the company had removed
a group called “E47”, which had mobilised both
military and non-military members to report
posts they did not like to Facebook in an effort
to have them taken down. The source said the
group was connected to a list of Force 47 groups
identified by Reuters.
A Facebook spokesperson confirmed that
some groups and accounts were taken down on
Thursday for “coordinating attempts to mass
report content.” A company source said the
action was one of Facebook’s largest takedowns
initiated under its mass reporting policy.
(Pearson 2021)
Concerns about the Thai government’s approach
(and the approach of other Asian governments)
have been raised by the Office of the United Nations
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR):
In Thailand, the Anti-Fake News Center of the
Ministry of Digital Economy and Society and
the Technology Crime Suppression Division of
Royal Thai Police are conducting joint operations
to address social media content deemed to be
“disinformation” in the COVID-19 context. There
are concerns that people raising legitimate issues
of public interest related to COVID-19 are also
being targeted, and such action may create an
atmosphere of self-censorship. One example is a
Thai artist arrested on 23 April for posting concern
about the apparent lack of screening measures
in Suvarnabhumi airport upon his arrival from
abroad on 16 April. He was released on bail and
has since been indicted. (OHCHR 2020)
In Pakistan, pro-government “fact checkers”
have engaged in online harassment of journalists
who have criticized the government, and these
journalists’ reporting has been labelled “fake news”
(Jahangir 2021b).
INTERNET SHUTDOWNS AND WEBSITE
BLOCKS
Tackling fake news and hate speech has become
a common reason that governments advance for
shutting down the internet and blocking certain
websites. A report by Access Now records that 196
internet shutdowns took place worldwide in 2018,
with Asia and Africa being the most affected regions.
“Fake news” or “hate speech” was the third most
common justification provided by governments
(Taye and Access Now 2018).
For example, in 2018, the Sri Lankan government
blocked access to Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram,
and Viber in the aftermath of anti-Muslim mob
violence (Goel, Kumar, and Frenkel 2018). In
December 2018, mobile operators were instructed
by the telecoms regulator of Bangladesh to shut
down high-speed mobile internet services until
midnight on election day. The reason given was
“to prevent rumors and propaganda surrounding
the vote” (Reuters 2018). In 2018, in Tripura, India,
the government blocked SMS, mobile internet, and
data services for twenty-eight hours. A news article
from The Economic Times reported that the director
general of police sought the blocking of these media
following an incident where a person was lynched
by a mob who suspected him of being a child
kidnapper (Singh 2018). A 2020 article by Human
Rights Watch observed the following in relation to
Myanmar:
Asia – 2 1 6
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents