there were a large number of actors driven by
financial interests, cooperating with others in
a decentralized pattern” (Tseng et al. 2020, v).
Furthermore,
specific narratives have dominated the 2020
Taiwan general election campaign, such as
“Democracy is a failure,” which supports the view
that democracy in Taiwan has failed to give the
people good governance, positive international
relationships, and a strong economy, and
that democracy leads to moral decadence.
“Democracy is a failure” was a constant narrative
that played out during the presidential election
campaign up until the COVID-19 pandemic.
(Tseng et al. 2020, vi)
In Central Asia, the influence of content from Russia
cannot be discounted. Lola Islamova, founder,
director, and editor of the news agency Anhor.uz,
noted that state propaganda is a big part of the
problem of misinformation in Uzbekistan. The role of
Russian media is especially significant. She explains
that certain demographic groups, like elderly
viewers, prefer to watch Russian TV channels for
information and entertainment, and these channels
often contain disinformation. Based on Islamova
and her team’s monitoring of online content, they
concluded that Uzbek-language content and
Russian-language content have different audiences,
and as a result there are differences in how
misinformation manifests. Misinformation in Uzbek
is often linked to religion, whereas consumers of
content in Russian in Uzbekistan tend to be more
educated, and simple misinformation related to
religious differences may not have great traction
among them (interview, 2021).
Similarly, Duman Smaqov, head and editor of
the website Factcheck.kz, noted that some of the
trolls and bots active in Kazakhstan seem to be
originating from Russia, judging by the language,
style, and examples used. He explained that many
of these bots are very developed and seem to
be actively posting information and following
each other; to a layperson they may appear to be
authentic accounts. Compared to bots and fake
accounts in Kazakhstan, those in Kyrgyzstan seem
to be a bit less advanced. Partners of Smaqov and
his team from the website Factcheck.kg noticed
an increase in such accounts during the elections
(interview, 2021).
It has also been noted that border disputes (such
as the one between Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan) can
give rise to information disorder. Torokul Doorov
observed that during the recent Tajik–Kyrgyz border
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
conflict, there were videos of army vehicles at the
border and descriptions implying the mobilization
of the army at the border. However, it turned out
that the videos were old or actually from another
country (interview, 2021).
Injina Panthi, a fact checker from South Asia
Check, has also observed anti-Indian sentiments
contributing to information disorder in Nepal:
“For example, there is one politician, she spoke
Hindi in our Parliament. So people [created] a
perception about her—that
she is pro-Indian and can’t
Injina Panthi, a fact checker
be loyal towards Nepal—and
from South Asia Check, has
disseminated
information
also observed anti-Indian
accordingly on social media”
sentiments contributing to
(interview, 2021).
information disorder in Nepal.
Similarly, Jason Cabañes,
professor of communication
and research fellow in the Department of
Communication, De La Salle University, observed
that tensions between the Philippines and China
over the South China Sea and, more recently, the
Covid-19 pandemic have led to discriminatory
attitudes towards Chinese migrant workers in the
Philippines, and even towards Filipinos of Chinese
descent:
And from both camps, those supporting and
those who are against the administration, they’re
putting out misinformation, or disinformation,
that’s amplifying negative sentiments against
the [Chinese] migrants who are here. And then,
even more importantly, it becomes extended.
This is even more scary for Filipinos of Chinese
descent or with Chinese heritage. They are very
well integrated into the Philippine population—
they’ve been here since the Spanish colonial
period, [but now] they are becoming part of this
discourse. So it’s becoming very xenophobic and
nativist. (interview, 2021)
HEALTH
While health-related mis- and disinformation has
often existed (for example the promotion of fake
medicines and cures, organ donation scams, etc.),
the Covid-19 pandemic has led to the dissemination
of a large volume of mis- and disinformation
specifically related to the novel coronavirus. Topics
include fake cures (for example in India, where
this issue is linked to ethnonationalist sentiments),
mis- and disinformation about Covid-19 vaccines,
and claims accusing certain ethnic, national, and
religious groups of being “spreaders” of the virus. In
addition, state-backed campaigns have been used
Asia – 1 9 6
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents