are planning to do so because they have noticed
that whenever a major political event occurs, there
is an intensification of fake accounts on
social media. Trolls appear to be linked to
In some cases, political
government figures or certain opposition
campaigns and candidates
figures, but this has not yet been verified.
have been targeted on the
Doorov stated that this observation is
basis of religion or ethnicity.
based on the similarities in the style,
languages, and phrases that tend to be
used in comments left by these fake accounts in
response to their articles.
In some cases, political campaigns and
candidates have been targeted on the basis of
religion or ethnicity. For example, in the 2016 Jakarta
gubernatorial elections, the incumbent governor,
Basuki Tjahaja Purnama (a Christian with ethnic
Chinese ancestry in Muslim-majority Indonesia),
was accused of blasphemy on the basis of a
misleadingly edited video of one of his speeches,
implying that he had insulted or misinterpreted a
verse in the Koran (Columbia University 2021). He
was prosecuted and sentenced to two years in
prison. He lost the elections.
Likewise, Nalaka Gunawardene, a science writer
and media analyst in Sri Lanka, has observed the
promotion of ethno-nationalist narratives in the
run-up to elections:
Come election time [...], it used to be the “Ali Koti
Giwisuma” allegation always levelled against
the UNP [United National Party], for a quarter
century. No evidence was ever produced, but
the rival camps only had to say, “Ah, there is this
secret deal with the Tigers [LTTE guerilla group].”
Now what they say is, again, that the UNP has
some secret deal to sell national assets to the
West, and it’s “un-fact-checkable.” And yet it is
the kind of false narrative that will immediately
gain traction. In decisive times, like five days
before an election and national elections, these
things do matter. (interview, 2021)
Women’s rights activists have also found themselves
the targets of hate speech. For example, Ramsha
Jahangir, a journalist in Pakistan, observed:
For instance, organizers of this women’s rights
march have also been accused of treason. There
have been cases filed against them in the court
to ban them, calling for them to be hanged as
well, because they were accused of blasphemy
last year. It’s very intense and, of course, it
threatens the safety and lives of participants of
the march. Their pictures have been leaked, their
private information has been leaked. And it’s
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
more than a hate comment or cyberbullying. Of
course, it is accompanied by that as well. There
have been alternate hate campaigns, online hate
campaigns at the same time, like “Ban Aurat
marchers” or “Hang these blasphemers” or these
hashtags have also trended. But on the ground,
it is worse. It’s very, very blatant. And this is why
women’s rights activists have been asking the
state to do something about it, to provide safety,
because all they’re asking for is a women’s rights
celebration; whatever they’re demanding is not
something that should put their lives at risk. But
the situation has definitely escalated more and
more [in recent] years. Opponents also were
throwing rocks and attacking the marchers in the
capital in Islamabad. So it’s definitely both offline
and online, [and] it’s very big. (interview, 2021)
In the Philippines, Cheryll Ruth Soriano, a professor
in the Department of Communication of De La
Salle University, studies “historical distortion.”
She investigates YouTube videos which attempt
to whitewash or downplay atrocities committed
during the Marcos regime’s era of martial law: “In
another study [we were doing] that was not about
politics, these narratives from these YouTubers that
surfaced in our research came up several times.
That’s how we learned that your regular driver, your
regular students are using these YouTube videos
as their sources of educational information about
their history” (interview, 2021). This is significant,
as members of the Marcos family still have political
aspirations.
Foreign disinformation campaigns have
been observed, as well as geopolitical tensions
contributing to information disorder. For example, in
2020 the EU Disinfo Lab released a report in which
they stated that they had “uncovered a massive
operation targeting international institutions and
serving Indian interests: “‘Indian Chronicles’—the
name we gave to this operation—resurrected
dead media, dead think-tanks and NGOs. It even
resurrected dead people. This network is active in
Brussels and Geneva in producing and amplifying
content
to
undermine—primarily—Pakistan”
(Alaphilippe, Adamczyk, and Grégoire 2020).
Similarly, Doublethink Lab in Taiwan released a
report in 2020 on information operations based
in China targeting the 2020 general elections in
Taiwan. According to the report, “During Taiwan’s
2020 general election there were countless
disseminators of disinformation, residing in both
China and Taiwan. In addition to politically-oriented
disinformation manufacturers and distributors,
Asia – 1 95
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents