4. COUNTERING
INFORMATION
DISORDER
The strategies and methodologies proposed by
the literature to counter information disorder are
derived from the theoretical and empirical understanding of the factors which engender it. Current
scholarship emphasizes the promotion of media
literacy for the public and media practitioners,
the development of communication strategies informed by an understanding of the production and
consumption of falsified information, the promotion
of access to credible information, data-powered
fact-checking strategies, and multifaceted interventions which bring together diverse stakeholders
(Seo et al. 2021).
Studies conducted in Kenya, Nigeria, South
Africa, and Zimbabwe have found that
information disorder has penetrated various
fields of economic activity, impacting on the
functionality of various sectors and actors such as
public health, financial services, job recruitment,
elections, and so forth.
Media and information literacy programs are
based on the assumption that societies will
increasingly be datafied and the public inundated
with information. Media and information literacy
programs are therefore seen as necessary efforts
that must be sustained to target the primary
consumers of news media and information. Broadly,
media and information literacy empowers citizens
with competencies which will enable them to
access, critically analyze, create, and consume
information. It is, however, also seen as a means for
societies to realize their right to access information
and to exercise their freedom of expression—
based on the idea that literacy will increase the
demand for credible information and promote
informed expression amongst producers of news
and information. Such programs address the issue
of poor and/or compromised media that leads to
citizen distrust; they also aim to strengthen poor
journalistic practices (Seo et al. 2021).
The lack of trust in traditional news media
in sub-Saharan Africa has given rise to a series
of independent fact-checking organizations
and initiatives who, despite operating at the
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
periphery of media institutions, seek to improve
upon the journalistic practices that negatively
impact media credibility. These organizations or
initiatives investigate claims circulating on social
media or traditional media with the objective
of providing access to information and holding
media and politicians to account by engaging the
general public in news production (Cheruiyot and
Ferrer-Conill 2018). According to Africa’s first factchecking organization, which hosts the largest factchecking network on the continent, the practice of
fact checking serves two functions: countering the
spread of unverified and/or misleading information
and raising the general public’s awareness of how
to identify false claims and break circulation (Africa
Check 2020).
Research on fact-checking organizations and
their impact in sub-Saharan Africa is limited,
however. The key findings of an evaluation survey
conducted by Africa Check (2020) on its Africa Fact
network show that fact-checking organizations:
• value their audiences’ trust
• challenge normative traditional media practices
of anonymized sources by developing genuine
relationships with trustworthy sources who can
verify claims
• are committed and prepared to meet (through
training and understanding) the demands of the
ever-changing nature of information disorder
• account for the digital divide in Africa by diversifying working languages and the platforms they
use
• prioritize collaboration to stay abreast of new innovations and best practice.
On the other hand, some studies reveal that media
and information literacy and fact-checking practices
are a limited response to an issue propelled by
complex cultural and social shifts, which are further
compounded by the fast-tracked development
of information and communication technologies
(Wasserman and Madrid-Morales 2018).
There is, however, no one approach that works
best. The literature suggests a multi-levelled stakeholder approach combining various approaches
and/or forming alliances, taking into consideration the disparities between communities in Africa. Combating mis- and disinformation related to
Covid-19 will require a coordinated approach that
brings together the relevant authorities in public
and global health, government agencies, international development organizations, journalists,
fact-checking organizations, civil society entities,
and community leaders to develop communication
Sub -Saharan Africa – 1 70