Contd. P19: Pakistan
Pakistan and Geedge
Geedge’s codename for their Pakistan project is P19. According to the evidence in the new
documents, Geedge’s operations in the country did not begin until 2023. This aligns with
when Sandvine ended their contract with Pakistan in November 2023, responding to
sanctions imposed by the United States Department of Commerce.50
The Geedge version of Pakistan’s national firewall, which Amnesty International Security
Lab calls WMS 2.0, includes new functionalities courtesy of TSG-OS. The modern firewall
can store details about who is using a censorship circumvention tool and which IPaddresses visited which websites. It can monitor the internet traffic as well as telephone
communications within the country and can track and block access to circumvention tools
such as VPNs and specific websites.
The language used by a senior Pakistan ISP executive in an interview with Al Jazeera,
mirrors Geedge marketing materials closely.51 The unnamed executive said the new WMS
was being deployed not only at the country’s internet gateways but at local data centers of
mobile service providers and ISPs.52 Because the previous system was only able to surveil
content entering and exiting the country, Pakistan was not able to censor content hosted
by local caching content delivery networks (CDNs) like those run by Netflix and Meta.
Comparing WMS 1.0 and WMS 2.0, the executive said: “Unlike the Sandvine system, the
new DPI-based system is now capable of monitoring local internet traffic,” using an “in-line
network” which also had a higher likelihood of slowing down internet speeds for users. The
executive also noted that the Chinese (Geedge) technology provides the capability to
manage applications and websites at a “granular level”, providing better features than
Sandvine.
Unlike other countries using Geedge services, there are not national or regional centers in
Pakistan. Instead, and likely a remnant of the old Sandvine system, Geedge is installed at
three sites: PCAP (the generic term for data center and noted for “backup”), MSH (where
most of the TSG hardware is), TWA (likely the Karachi Submarine Cable Landing Station
owned by the company Transworld Associates).