“I do think the intentions
(exercising social punishment)
there are correct because a
lot of the country’s detriment
comes from the corruption of
these families and a lot of the
people struggling here have
these families to thank for
that, who are stealing from
the people money or resources
here. When it first started
out, it was “clean” if people
are just getting to know who
the families are. But I think
that people here, especially
on Facebook, can go to the
extremes, and for example post
not just pictures but nudes,
horrible graphic pictures about
these families that are bad
and terrible and have done
terrible things but it raises
a completely different issue,
that would be harassment in any
case. It also turns it into a
personal vendetta, people also
add people they have personal
issues with, to affect their
reputation.” (FGD_05)
34
“In my opinion I don’t think
it is fair to shame the
people who don’t join CDM it
is an individual decision,
and each individual has a
different family situation and
personal situation. We need
to understand the personal
background of each individual,
that’s why we shouldn’t do
social punishment to those who
decide not to join the CDM.”
(FGD_04) (Rakhine)
“In Myanmar, the military use
their weapons not to protect,
but to kill people. The people
have no weapon, they only have
their mouth and their voice
on social media. That is the
only way to fight back at
them. Somebody who supports
the military, they condemn
them. For a normal country,
it doesn’t matter. It can be
bullying if some people make a
group to bully others. But if
he/she is supporting a group
who is killing a lot of people
and violating human rights,
they are working against
humanity. So, the community
must condemn it. I think that
is an ethic here as well. Even
with monkeys, if one monkey
tries to abuse or rape the
small monkey, the rest of them
kill that monkey, because they
think that is dangerous for
their monkey society.” (KII_03)
“Free expression should not
harm, Social punishment is
intended to harm, that’s
why I don’t think it can be
considered an element of free
expression.” (FGD_02)
“We need to participate
otherwise we will get judged”
(FGD_07) (Female)
“That’s the way people are
exercising their revolution
and their way to fight against
authoritarianism. I think it’s
ok, as long as they don’t
harm individuals in any way
physically. Killing them, or
physically attacking them is
way beyond social punishment.
It is just to do with business
and punishing them in terms
of banning them from social
activities and stuff.”
(KII_02) (Male)