16
Policy Brief No. 45
Toda Peace Institute
entrepreneur and political organiser Maciej Czeglowski pointed out in his excellent 2019
Senate testimony about digital privacy.
In general, while banning or deindexing may be tempting to “keep the peace,” suppressing
speech entirely is unlikely to build peace. Banning and deindexing should be treated as
extreme options, used with enormous care and transparency. (The Electronic Frontier Foundation has a good, short guide about this.) Unfortunately, they are not being handled carefully right now, which is both inflaming tensions across the globe and opening avenues for
potential future institutional abuse.
Authoritarian governments are proving adept at mastering digital platforms, censoring
them where desired, and using them for surveillance and propaganda. This may create
“peace” in some sense, but at catastrophic cost to human rights. Democracies hoping to build
peace must develop strategies that respect both individual expression, and rights such as
privacy. The rapid scaling of digital media platforms has become an uncontrolled social
experiment, but there is still time to inject a healthy dose of transparency and accountability.