Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 52 (2020)
Crime as Cognitive Constraint
still heavily prosecuted under draconian defamation laws. 90 This creates
a chilling effect on public participation and free press coverage of
sensitive political events. 91 Further, state-owned media remain
unmatched in terms of resources and reach, 92 enabling the state to
manage public discourse effectively. Ironically, democracy gave more
impetus for state ownership of media channels as a way to “amplify the
government’s messaging.” 93
Against this background, Facebook carved out a space where the
“tea shop and the 8 o’clock news meet.” 94 In the Myanmar context, the
8 o’clock news represented the sanitized news that was typically aired
during pre-2011 Myanmar, while the tea shop provided a
“quintessential…place to learn…what the 8 o’clock news was not [then]
discussing.” 95 Combining these two metaphors, Facebook served as the
place where both “military leaders and activists share the same virtual
space, and where there is no direct way for state authorities to control
or censor dissenting voices.” 96 Myanmar’s socio-political context thus
magnifies the importance of platforms, similar to other Global South
contexts such as Kenya. 97 Despite military ownership of media
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-myanmar-censorshipidUSBRE87J06N20120820.
90.
See Christopher Zara, Jailed For A Facebook Poem: The Fight Against
Myanmar’s Draconian Defamation Laws, FASTCOMPANY (July 13, 2017),
https://www.fastcompany.com/40438242/jailed-for-a-facebook-poemthe-fight-against-myanmars-draconian-defamation-laws.
91.
Defamation is currently penalized under six different laws, some of which
allow criminal complaints to be filed by persons other than the person
allegedly defamed. For an overview, see Gayathry Venkiteswaran, Yin
Yadanar Thein & Myint Kyaw, Legal Changes for Media and Expression:
New Reforms, Old Controls, in MYANMAR MEDIA IN TRANSITION:
LEGACIES, CHALLENGES AND CHANGE 59 (Lisa Brooten, Jane Madlyn
McElhone & Gayathry Venkiteswaran eds., 2019).
92.
See Myanmar Profile - Media, BBC NEWS (May
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-12991727.
93.
Michelle J. Foster, The Business Environment for News Media in
(2018),
Myanmar:
2018,
INTERNEWS
https://internews.org/resource/business-environment-news-mediamyanmar-2018.
94.
Yan Naung Oak and Lisa Brooten, The Tea Shop Meets the 8 O’clock
News: Facebook, Coveregence and Online Public Spaces, MYANMAR
MEDIA IN TRANSITION: LEGACIES, CHALLENGES AND CHANGE 325, 329 (Lisa
Brooten, Jane Madlyn McElhone, Gayathry Venkiteswaran, eds., 2019).
95.
Id. at 328.
96.
Id. at 329.
97.
NANJALA NYABOLA, DIGITAL DEMOCRACY, ANALOGUE POLITICS: HOW THE
INTERNET IS TRANSFORMING THE POLITICS IN KENYA 204-205 (2018)
159
2,
2017),