platforms. Referring to her research on
election disinformation, the Syrian civil
war, and conspiratorial explanations
of mass shootings, Starbird told NPR
in 2021: “Over and over again, YouTube is the dominant domain in those
conversations [on social media]. It's not
Facebook. They're all pulling in content
from YouTube.”48
Monetizing content
Whether one seeks to hawk workout
tips or an ideological agenda, certain
YouTube features, or affordances,
facilitate finding a loyal audience—and
potentially profiting in the process.
YouTube “creators” can use an ordinary
smart phone to record themselves and
then upload the video to a self-created YouTube channel. Other YouTube
users may subscribe to the channel
free of charge. After accumulating
1,000 subscribers and 4,000 annual
“watch hours,” a creator may apply
to YouTube’s Partner Program and, if
approved, begin receiving a portion
of revenue generated by advertising.
Typically, the creator receives up to
55% of the revenue, with the company
retaining about 45%. The ads are sold
and distributed by Google’s AdSense
service and placed immediately before
or after the creator’s videos.49 The
extent to which creators can “monetize” video content sets YouTube apart
from other platforms, which provide
money-making opportunities but on a
smaller scale. YouTube creators who
have tens of thousands of subscribers
can clear five figures a year; those with
hundreds of thousands or millions can
pocket six figures.
Tim Pool: Hosting Far-Right Headliners
YouTube creator Tim Pool provides a platform to far-right figures such as Alex
Jones of Infowars and Enrique Tarrio of the Proud Boys. YouTube shares ad
revenue with Pool, whose channels collectively have millions of subscribers.
He also generates income by selling merchandise and holding Super Chats,
which allow viewers of live-stream videos to pay to have their comments
posted prominently. The day before the January 6 assault on the Capitol, fans
of Timcast IRL paid modest amounts to elevate comments such as, “Prepare
yourselves - the wicked and immoral will be annihilated — this is the only way”
($6.66) and “The time of war is here. Only a fool still has faith in the courts”
($4.99). In an email, Pool told us: “We don’t control what others say, and we
can’t do anything about people’s free speech.” He added that his team has
“worked with YouTube to deter calls for violence and extremism.”
10
HOW YOUTUBE SPREADS HARMFUL CONTENT – AND WHAT CAN BE DONE ABOUT IT
Creators have money-making opportunities other than splitting ad revenue.
In the Super Chat program, for example,
they can offer viewers of live-stream videos the chance to pay modest amounts
to have their written comments pinned to
the top of the live-chat feed for a longer
period of time. Creators typically keep
70% of this cash stream; YouTube takes
30%. “More creators than ever are earning money from our non-ads products
like Super Chat,” Pichai, Google’s CEO,
said during a conference call with industry analysts in February 2022.50
The typical YouTube aesthetic is do-ityourself TV: a performer who speaks
directly to the audience with memes
and video clips interspersed. Incurring
negligible production costs, creators
can foster an air of intimacy and credibility that is largely absent from platforms
like Facebook and Twitter. Rebecca
Lewis, a Ph.D candidate at Stanford in
communications theory, has identified
a populous network of conservative
YouTube creators, ranging from mainstream Republicans to overt white
supremacists, whose audiences overlap
and share agendas such as attacking
“woke” liberals and revealing imaginary
“deep state” conspiracies. They visit
like-minded channels and amplify each
other’s content, Lewis observes.51
YouTuber Tim Pool exemplifies the
“micro-celebrity” methods Lewis describes. A creator in his mid-thirties
who initially gained attention by livestreaming the 2011 left-wing Occupy
Wall Street protests, Pool in recent
years has often used his YouTube
appearances and interviews to amplify
divisive right-wing conspiracy theories.52
Appearing in a trademark black knit hat,
Pool operates a network of at least five
YouTube channels, which in total boast
millions of subscribers. Recent video
titles include: “Leaked Emails Implicate
Biden Family in UKR [Ukraine] Biolab
Scandal, Media Caught Lying” and
“Vaccine Passport Chip Implants Are
Real, Alex Jones Right AGAIN As More
Cities Declare Vax Mandates.”53 He has
hosted Jones and Enrique Tarrio, the
former chairman of the Proud Boys,
a violent hard-right group. Tarrio and