Fifty-three may seem like a large number of
platforms and organizations. However, in reality,
this is not enough to fact check facts in a region
raging with political crises, wars, revolutions,
and financial crises, and where disinformation
abounds, especially since many of these initiatives
are working voluntarily and are composed of small
teams with limited resources. The right to access
information is generally not upheld in the region,
while the press faces restrictions, especially in
the case of independent outlets. Therefore, these
platforms are up against big challenges.
Moreover, as will be detailed below, a large
number of these platforms and initiatives emerged
through volunteer efforts by journalists and activists
who recognized the great need to contribute to the
fight against information disorder in their countries,
even with almost non-existent human and material
resources. For funding, most of these organizations
rely on international organizations, donations, and
individual funding. A few larger organizations and
platforms for fact-checking services in Arabic have
emerged, such as AFP Fact Check, Fatabyyano,
Misbar, Tech 4 Peace, and a few others.
4.1 CHARACTERISTICS OF
FACT-CHECKING INITIATIVES,
PLATFORMS, AND
ORGANIZATIONS IN
THE REGION
We analyzed the work of fact-checking platforms
in the region and the challenges they face. We
then sent a questionnaire to thirty-two platforms,
initiatives, and organizations in fourteen Arab
countries. We received twenty-six responses from
thirteen countries: two from Algeria, three from
Egypt, one from Iraq, two from Jordan, four from
Lebanon, three from Libya, one from Morocco, two
from Palestine, one from Saudi Arabia, one from
Sudan, two from Syria, three from Tunisia, and one
from Yemen.
The organizations that responded to the
questionnaire were mostly fairly young. The majority
(sixteen out of twenty-six) were established
between 2019 and 2021, while the remaining ten
were established between 2012 and 2018. This
suggests that the massive spread of misleading
and false information in the Arab world during the
Covid-19 crisis encouraged the establishment of
specialized initiatives and organizations dedicated
to fact checking, because of the crucial role that it
can play in confronting mis- and disinformation.
I N FO R M ATI O N D I SO R D ER IN THE GLOBA L SOUTH
The organizations use different organizational
and funding models. Eleven of the twentysix initiatives are registered companies, while
eight are volunteer-based initiatives, four are
individual initiatives, and three are affiliated
with media platforms. Most of these platforms
and organizations obtain their funding from
international organizations and individuals. Most
of them work with fewer than ten employees or
volunteers.
The organizations aim to create awareness
of their work by building a public profile. Most of
these initiatives and organizations have websites
and accounts on various social media sites, while
three of them also use smartphone applications
(see Table 1).
While most of these organizations focus on fact
checking in a local context, some of them have
a regional and global scope. Fourteen of these
initiatives and organizations focus on fact checking
within a local (national) context. One is active
regionally and two are active in a global framework,
while a further nine focus on the national, regional,
and international frameworks, particularly during
important and international events that might
interest Arab readers.
The focus of these initiatives, organizations,
and platforms is mainly on checking political
news, followed by social content, and then health
and economic content. These are followed by
government content, government speeches, and
political promises. The technological, artistic,
cultural, and sports spheres occupy the lowest
levels of interest. Due to the many political,
social, and economic crises that Arab countries
are experiencing, these are not considered to be
priority areas.
Many of these initiatives, organizations, and
platforms are not very active, because they face
financial constraints and
their teams are small and
Many of these initiatives,
composed of volunteers.
organizations, and platforms
Five of them verify only
are not very active, because
one piece of news or conthey face financial constraints
tent per day; fourteen of
and their teams are small and
them verify between one
composed of volunteers.
and five items per day; five
of them verify between
five and ten items per day. Only two of them verify
between ten and twenty items per day. Although
most of these platforms allow the public to send
them news, photos, videos, and other types of content for verification purposes, audience interaction
with these platforms is fairly low across the region.
Middle East and North Africa – 32