Spotlight: Social Media in Southeast Asia
Echo Chambers and a Sectarian
Public Sphere in Southeast Asia
Ross Tapsell examines how ‘echo chambers’ online are segregating the public sphere in Southeast Asia.
T
he term ‘echo chamber’ has been popularised in recent
times to describe the shifting state of news consumption
brought about by digitalisation. A media ‘echo chamber’ is
where people tend to migrate towards information and news
which they agree with. In practical terms, this is done by
clicking on headlines and following news sites and opinionmakers who conform to one’s worldview. At the same, ‘echo
chambers’ are exemplified by removing oneself from social
media groups or news sites which do not conform to your
political, cultural or ideological views. The precise impact
of ‘echo chambers’ is contested by scholars, and indeed
highly variable according an individual’s willingness to
expand or reduce their information flows. It is possible, of
course, for someone to have a wide view of the world simply
by being on Twitter, for example, by following a range of
people and news sites. It is equally possible for someone to
be active on Twitter or Facebook but subscribe only to sites
which are of the same political persuasion, and therefore
their idea of a topic or issue is quite narrow.
In Southeast Asia, ‘echo chambers’ online can be exploited
around religious and ethnic divisions. Just recently, Reuters
uncovered “more than 1,000 examples of posts, comments
images and videos denigrating and attacking the Rohingya
and other Muslims” on Facebook. In Indonesia, there has
14 — ISSUE 5/2018
been much discussion about online ‘wars’ of ‘buzzers’ who
look to push partisan viewpoints, most notably the socalled Muslim Cyber Army. The group has been accused of
spreading “fake news and hate speech to inflame religious
and ethnic schisms.” These partisan groups are aiming
to incite and enrage readers online in order to push their
political or ideological agenda, and those audiences who
are heavily in their ‘bubble’ are arguably more likely to be
convinced of their views.
As more and more young Southeast Asians get their news
solely from social media platforms like Facebook, the
greater the power of the platform to play a larger role in
influencing their worldviews. In the Philippines, described
as ‘a Facebook nation,’ social media commentators who
provide ‘alternative’ news and views on Facebook are
highly popular, and their support for current President
Duterte was crucial in his 2016 election campaign.
Big data analytics can exacerbate this situation, particularly
around election time. Big data analytics enables us to better
understand the nuances of particular groups online. For
example, a big data company could ascertain that female
workers in Johor, Malaysia would largely vote for a party
which has a policy to reduce immigration to the state. The