Who buys and controls the CCTV?
Back to contents
64
Right to freedom of
expression
Freedom of expression and privacy are mutually reinforcing rights. Privacy
is a prerequisite to the meaningful exercise of freedom of expression,
particularly given its role in preventing state and corporate surveillance
that stifles free expression. Freedom of expression is fundamental to
political dissent, diverse cultural expression, creativity, and innovation, as
well as the development of one’s personality through self-expression.
The right to freedom of expression is protected by Article 19 of the UDHR
and given legal force through Article 19 of the ICCPR, as well as in regional
human rights treaties. Under international human rights standards,
restrictions on the right to freedom of expression are permitted only if
they meet the three-part test of legality, necessity, and proportionality; all
restrictions must be strictly and narrowly tailored and may not put the
right itself in jeopardy.125
The installation of CCTV cameras as discussed in this report interferes
with the freedom of expression in multiple ways. The politics of where
these systems will be installed, and their intended use, introduce a new
layer of political and social intimidation – neighbourhoods that are
being ‘watched’ more closely will bear the brunt of the vicious cycle of
over-policing.
Mass surveillance has a chilling effect on freedom of expression.126 Studies
show that the awareness of being watched and tracked might lead
people not to join public assemblies, participate in social and cultural
life, or freely express their thoughts, conscience, and religious beliefs in
public spaces.127 It also directly compels people to alter their behaviours –
particularly in their political life – out of fear of being arrested, harassed,
and otherwise singled out by repressive regimes. The intention of ubiquity
and tracking implicit in Myanmar’s current CCTV procurement discussed