Who buys and controls the CCTV?
Back to contents
14
In this report, ARTICLE 19 and Digital Rights Collective investigate how one
particular component of smart cities in Myanmar – CCTVs – are procured.
This is an important area of investigation for several reasons.
First, CCTV cameras form the infrastructural backbone of a host of emerging
technologies – including AI applications like facial and emotion recognition.
The mission creep embedded in technical and policy design for CCTVs go
from simply being installed cameras for ‘safety’, to being equipped to carry
out remote biometric identification. Verification capabilities are normalised
across policy documents but are rarely logistically understood. We focus on
CCTV infrastructure generally, not just on one specific application like facial
recognition or automated number plate recognition, as it is often
technologies like traditional CCTVs which facilitate the easy transition to
AI-based surveillance simply by layering on newer applications without
adequate scrutiny. In this report, we trace how CCTVs as an infrastructural
building block of smart cities, in particular, are installed in the first place
and ask how they may evolve in the future. We analyse these developments
through a human rights lens. We also provide a preliminary analysis of
CCTV installation in three cities in Myanmar to help the reader understand
these developments against the background of national priorities.
Second, this research is published at a particularly unique juncture in
Myanmar’s political reality: it began when the civilian-elected National
League for Democracy (NLD) government was in power, and subsequently
developed during and after the military coup in February 2021. There was
an intensifying crackdown against protesters and activists in Myanmar
after the military coup. As the new State Administrative Council formed
after the coup, taking control of the country’s legislations, governance,
infrastructure, and technology, concerns surrounding potential uses
and impacts of smart cities’ infrastructure have evolved and become
increasingly urgent. Images of authorities monitoring protest movements
in traffic control centres were shared over social media.9 With the military
authoring new legislations and taking control of infrastructure and
technology, there are increasing indications that the existing smart cities’
infrastructure will be used to monitor people who are engaged in civic
participation and exercising their rights to free expression.10